timing advance question

Status
Not open for further replies.

KartFab

Active member
Messages
3,381
Reaction score
60
Location
Dallas, TX
so, whats up with this timing stuff. I am constantly hearing, 'advance by 6-12 degrees' blah blah and im trying to get the concept down

so TDC is when piston is highest, ok got that
BTDC is what the timing is set to, so degrees before top dead center

these little stock engines have about 25 degrees before top dead center as their timing, and you need to advance that to whatever to continue to make power at higher rpms.... ok understandable

i hear the standard ok so 6-8ish is good for most mild cams, check..... so advance to 31ish-33ish.

got a piston stop on the way, degree wheel i already have, timing light on the way, yes it woudl be easier to just get an offset key and be done with it, but I want it to be exact....

but i still dont get why it is that 'advancing' the timing is actually making the spark occur later... because TDC is when everything is getting compressed, right? so spark happens BEFORE that, at 25 degrees, so if you set it to 30+ degrees before top dead center, the spark is actually happening LATER compared to 25 degrees, and compared to top dead center... now im all confused, because I was under the impression that

1) it takes a certain amount of time for the flame to propogate
2) 'advancing' the timing helps start the flame sooner, to make up for the smaller time it has to burn in that cycle

now knowing that 'advancing' the timing, is just making it happen LATER?!?!?! compared to TDC.

I need some esplainin'
 

itsid

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,563
Reaction score
260
Location
Ruhrpott [Germany]
nono.. the spark is NOT happening later!
the actual spark -or let's say- the fuel ignition should happen at the "ideal" time no matter what;
(the ideal time is IIRC around 3-4° PAST TDC for the point where said ignition has the greates force on the piston [depends on the geometry of the cylinder and head])

The thing is, you cannot set that time directly, you can only set the time the coil gets the "discharge" signal...

and the faster the engine turns (the faster the flywheel progresses through the cycles) the earlier siad signal needs to be invoked in order to hit said sweet spot.
as trivial as that ;)

Now you can dig even deeper into this (flame speed of ignited fuel at temperature and commpression etc...)
but frankly, you want to tune an engine not sign up for a phd ;)
So let's just boil this part down to a single sentence:
The faster the engine rotates the earlier the fuel needs to be ignited to have it's maximum pressure at the ideal time [again just past TDC somewhere], since flame expansion is almost constant.

The spark of the plug or the ignition of the fuel are not yours to mess with,
you can only set the timing of the discharge (which as an effect influences time of spark and fuel ignition)
All related, none actually a constant ;)

'sid
 

Whitetrashrocker

Inmate #952016
Messages
5,235
Reaction score
4,731
Location
Southern New Mexico
Why are you so confused?
For a dummy example let's say timing should be at 0 degrees. Spark happens at the same time piston is at top of compression stroke.
Advancing the timing makes the spark happen before tdc and retarding timing makes it happen after.

That's all there is to it.

Now stock timing is at the 25 before tdc. That gives the flame time to fully ignite and producing max downwards pressure on piston. Advancing from here the 6 degrees would put it at 31 degrees Before tdc. And the same applies for retarding. Retard 6 degrees from stock would be at 19 degrees btdc.

The fuel ignition happens at the same rate so a faster spinning engine needs to get the fuel ignited sooner.
A slower turning torque monster can benefit from a little retarding in the timing.

---------- Post added at 12:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:29 PM ----------

Also, in the same respect, the reason for things like a vacuum advance on cars.
As the engine rpm increases the vacuum will increase and the vacuum advance would do just that advance the timing a little to help with the shorter burn time.
 

KartFab

Active member
Messages
3,381
Reaction score
60
Location
Dallas, TX
okay i had it all visualized wrong. I had to sit here and think about it for a minute. I assumed crank was stationary at tdc, with 25 deg before tdc, then rotate flywheel clockwise to redtard, and now the flywheel magnet is retarded compared to that, rotate flywheel counterclockwise, and now the magnet is more toward the magneto, which is also advancing the timing. duh. brain fart. thanks
 

Whitetrashrocker

Inmate #952016
Messages
5,235
Reaction score
4,731
Location
Southern New Mexico
I think you have it but just to clarify.
At the 0 degree timing setting for example;

Set piston to TDC.

The magnet on the flywheel will line up with the coil at the point it triggers the spark. In a points type set up this would be the time the points close, but with a mag field coil it's kinda hard to determine the exact point but that's above what where getting at. So just visualize an exact point.
Moving the flywheel only, counterclockwise would be retarding the timing. The piston would be on the downstroke when the coil triggered.
Clockwise would be advancing since the trigger would happen before the piston got to the top.

Now to mess you up, moving the coil is just opposite of what I said. Moving the coil ccw is advancing. And cw is retard.

This is the same as twisting the distributor cap on older cars.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top