Help with gear ratios please

Status
Not open for further replies.

Cstyle00

New member
Messages
60
Reaction score
1
Hey gentlemen, I'm almost finished modifiying my Manco 616 but I'm debating on which driven pulley to use. I can go with the 40 series or the 44 series. 40 series diameter is 7 1/2" the 44 is 8 1/2". The ratios I can go with are 1:1 - 2.14:1 with the 40 series or 1.24:1 - 2.83:1 with the 44 series. Keep in mind this is ratio given from pulley to pulley, sprocket and tires not factored here. I don't know much about gear ratios, is this a really big difference? I'm looking for more torque so I know should go with the 44 series but my motor mounts are already set for the 40. Does this ratio have a big difference in torque or is it really not enough to worry about. Thanks.
 

redsox985

Active member
Messages
4,092
Reaction score
12
Location
PA
For torque, you would want the 44. The motor mounts shouldn't matter because the driven mounts on the jackshaft anyways. Even if this is welded in place, you just need to buy the belt for the 44 driven with your current center distance.
 

Cstyle00

New member
Messages
60
Reaction score
1
Guys, thanks but your not answering the question asked, is there a significant amount of difference in the ratios. I know I would go with the 44 for more torque, I think I said that but how much difference is there in these ratios. Will I go from barely going up a hill to jumping it? Or is it really not that much a difference. Thing is I already bought the 40 series so really I'm wondering if it's worth paying the shipping on sending it back and having the other sent. If it helps I have a 9 tooth on jackshaft, 60 tooth on axle, and 18" tires. 13hp. Is there a torque converter calculator? Not much involved in changing it, just need to push the engine foward a little to get a belt to fit. Thanks for the input guys.
 

redsox985

Active member
Messages
4,092
Reaction score
12
Location
PA
I don't know much about gear ratios, is this a really big difference? I'm looking for more torque so I know should go with the 44 series but my motor mounts are already set for the 40. Does this ratio have a big difference in torque or is it really not enough to worry about.

Since you didn't know much about ratios, we tossed out some knowledge. You were right about the 44 giving more torque, although, the difference between the two won't be a dramatic difference. I would not take the time, cost, or effort to send it back. Remember, the belt is made for a certain center distance and should not be pulled tight. Reference your belt number for the 40 driven and the needed center distance, then use that measurement for your spacing.
 

r97

Measure twice cut once
Messages
3,793
Reaction score
9
Location
Massachusetts, USA
well, the 40 series ratio's have a range of 1.14, the 44 series has a range of 1.59.
1.14-1.59 =.45 so the difference in range of ratios between the two is .45, and if my math is correct it should be that the 44 series has a 40 percent higher range of ratios. if you ask me that is a decent amount more, and as long as its not too expensive, or too much hassle i would go with the 44 over the 40(as long as i got my math right:D).
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
The low range is 24.4% lower. The high range is 19.4% lower.

The way I view this, is that the benefit of the larger driven is that you can get away with a smaller axle sprocket to achieve similar speeds if you're concerned about ground clearance. This could mean the difference between a 60T axle sprocket, and a 45T. (25%-ish).
 

Cstyle00

New member
Messages
60
Reaction score
1
Ok first thing Redsox, I read what I wrote when I replied and I didn't mean to sound like an jerk, thanks for the input. I was just looking for something like r97 and toystory's answer but your right any extra knowledge is useful. Thanks to chez too.

Alright if you can run the math let's talk about it. Gimme some speeds if you can. 18" tires, 60 tooth sprocket on axle, 9 tooth on 5/8" jackshaft. 40 series driven is 7 1/2". 44 series driven is 8 1/2". 13hp engine

I know the 44 will slow the top end but if I'm mudding and rooting in the woods I need the torque. Thanks again.
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
Okay, here's what I got

40, 3600- final drive=6.67:1, 28.92MPH
44, 3600- final drive=8.27:1, 23.32MPH

Please note that est. top speeds are theoretical, and affected my many factors including TRUE tire size, drag, available HP, etc.
 

Cstyle00

New member
Messages
60
Reaction score
1
What? So your telling me I'm only going to go not even 24 miles per hour? It ran 28 with the 6.5 subaru and a 20 series torque converter. I hope that's not going to be the case. Did u factor in all the numbers I gave you? Lol, I'm eight hundred bux in not counting the frame, lol, I don't like what I'm hearing at all.
 

Cstyle00

New member
Messages
60
Reaction score
1
Yes, I did want low but I didn't want to kill my top speed. Something can't be right. How would a 6.5hp make the cart go up to 28mph and the new 13hp only 24mph? B/C I changed to a bigger torque converter? So I should have more torque, so I should be able to climb hills better than I did before, right? Hopefully I will know this weekend, everything comes in tomorrow and I had the 40 series changed to the 44 before it was shipped.

This has me really stressed now. I think I'm going to make another thread about this on just speeds and torque.
 

Cstyle00

New member
Messages
60
Reaction score
1
Is this going to work? Torque or speed?

44 series driven pulley 8 1/2", 9 tooth sprocket on 5/8" jackshaft, 60 tooth sprocket on axle, 18" dia. tires. Cart with driver around 350 pounds.

What will the speed be? How is it going to do on hills? Thanks pros.
 

redsox985

Active member
Messages
4,092
Reaction score
12
Location
PA
Common misconception. The 13 and 6.5 HPs both are governed at 3600 RPM. This means neither will go faster, the 13 HP will just have more grunt and torque. The ratio is everything unless you mod the 13HP. With the 13HP and lower ratio, you will be able to climb better, though.
 

Cstyle00

New member
Messages
60
Reaction score
1
Ok, so where do I find out how to modifiy the engine, what all can be done to a Greyhound?
 

Cstyle00

New member
Messages
60
Reaction score
1
Yea, that's what I was thinking, I may try a bigger sprocket on the jackshaft as well, guess I'll just have to play with it until I get what I'm looking for. The cost is getting pretty high, I'm starting to wonder how much a new go kart would have been already set up with a 13HP. I kinda wish I would have left it the way it was with th 6.5HP. Something has got to give, there's no way it's going to run the same when I'm finished, at least I hope, lol. Well, big time learning curve here.
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
Before you blow an O-ring, take a deep breath and re-asses the situation. While you're doing that, let me fill you in on my specs, they may help you.

GX340 (11hp), Comet 40/40, 4.8: final (10T & 48T), 17.5" actual measurement turf tires, approximate kart weight WITHOUT me, just over 300lbs. Measured top speed, 45MPH.
My governor is adjusted to allow about 4200RPM. Custom made Cherry Bomb muffler.
NO OTHER MODS!

My acceleration is not bad, torque is acceptable. I could probably gear down to about 5.5:1 for some improvement. Fair ability to climb mild hills.

What I'm getting at here, is that the CVT opens up a whole new world. When we calculate top speeds and gearing, we tend to get tunnel vision, focusing only on the high ratio, only on top speed. The very function of the CVT is to give us variable gear ratios, including the low range.

You don't HAVE to go as slow as we calculated, that was only based on your published specs. With some common sense, experience, and reasonable expectations, there should be no problem finding a ratio for you that will be a good compromise between grunt and speed. Remember, it is a compromise, though...

At any rate, let your parts come in, and meantime, we'll get it figured out. Once we've sellted on some numbers, you can go sprocket shopping...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top