Belt Vs. Chain

Status
Not open for further replies.

cjhols

New member
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Hi all.
I am attempting to build a Go Kart similar to the one listed here on YouTube. I have a 11 HP B&S vertical shaft from an old ride on and plan to use the diff which is 9:1 in top gear and the original tyres which are about 22".
I was thus looking for a drive ratio of 4:1. at the diff. Rather than using a torque converter can I just use a cent. clutch to the diff? and does it matter what size sprocket or pulley is used as long as it is 4 to 1?
Thanks
Peter

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7DaMK_v_Pno
 

bob58o

SuckSqueezeBangBlow
Messages
9,646
Reaction score
1,866
Location
Chicago-town USA
and does it matter what size sprocket or pulley is used as long as it is 4 to 1?
48T:12T = 4:1
60T:15T = 4:1
12" : 3" = 4:1

Gear ratio is same.
It MIGHT be easier on belt chain if using the bigger option, but only guessing on that part.

---------- Post added at 02:16 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:06 AM ----------

Are you suggesting a 9*4 =36

36:1 gear ratio with 22" Tires?? It will go 6.5mph at 3600rpm with crazy torque. What am I missing here?
 

cjhols

New member
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
O'h I just checked the back wheels and they're actually 16".
The other data I have just based on the guy's kart in the YouTube clip but you might be able to help a little more. I obviously don't want to race this beast but I would like to optimise Torque Vs. Speed (leaning towards speed). I would just like to use a cent. clutch from the drive shaft to the diff. (In top gear the ratio of the Diff is 9:1 rev of rear wheel). I also thought it would be easier to use a belt but I'm easily swayed.
Any ideas?
Thanks Peter
 

bob58o

SuckSqueezeBangBlow
Messages
9,646
Reaction score
1,866
Location
Chicago-town USA
A small go kart with small wheels might take a 6:1 final drive ratio.
A larger, heavier vehicle with larger wheels might need a 9:1 final drive ratio.
A 8:1 final drive ratio with 16" Tires will give you

21.5mph at 3600 rpm

I am unfamiliar with how the riding mower gearing works, but for an example when using a Torque Converter.....

Lowest gear for a larger kart might be 24:1 (final drive ratio) and highest gear might be 7.2:1 (final drive ratio).

Hopefully someone will chime in about the power train and trans you are asking about, but I just don't know.
 

bob58o

SuckSqueezeBangBlow
Messages
9,646
Reaction score
1,866
Location
Chicago-town USA
I watched the video again and checked the comments.

He linked a Torque Converter that he used and said it was slow and built for a 10 year old.

Most comments I've read mention these being geared to low for good speed, but again... beyond my scope of knowledge.

I found this...
http://gokartguru.com/rider_lawn_mower_gearbox.php


Riding Lawn Mower Gear Box?

Question:

I have a vertical engine and a vertical transaxle. Can't I just use the transaxle on my go kart? It should be easier this way right?

Answer: Great question. Many people are asking the same question. "I have this old lawn tractor and it has this transaxle, can I use it?

Vertical Engine Problem

The problem with a vertical engine is routing the power from the engine to the horizontal wheels on the go kart.

Typically the standard method for transferring the power involves a gear box.

For example on a lawn tractor the gearbox is designed with a pulley on the top of the gear box (probably very similar to what you are asking about.)

Additionally, because the main purpose of a riding lawnmower is to cut grass, the vertical engine layout works very well for driving a mower deck too.

The temptation comes in to play to use the gear box in the gokart and keep the unit simple that way. Unfortunately, it is not really simpler, but more complex, not to mention unrealiable.

Transaxle Problems and Pitfalls

Additionally, I would strongly steer you away from using a riding lawnmower gearbox for the following reasons:

- Width of the rear axel system is too narrow.

The width of a gokart drive wheel layout should be relatively speaking wide: 36”+ for good stablility and anti-roll characteristics.

Riding lawnmowers are under that width, being naturally unstable and very prone to tippage.

Also the gear box will pose a difficulty in powering the rear wheels. Mounting the gearbox is another issue that requires special bracketry that would need to be fabricated and mounted to the framework.

-Gear boxes are not designed for high speed as in 20+ mph. This is a serious consideration, especially with gear boxes that do not require lubrication and do not have roller bearings. The gear box may end up siezing up.

-Gear Box Engagement requires belt tensioning devices. Typically, the gearbox is activated by tensioning the belt. To answer your question about internal clutches, most gear boxes are not that sophisticated, they just require the belt to be tensioned to engage the gear box.

Belt Tensioning systems also require careful thought (complexity) in their design so that the activation of the clutch can be deactivated when the rider is starting, or idling the go kart.

-Switching gears on the fly is not possible without good engine/gearbox knowledge. The gearbox on a riding lawnmower does not have synchronizers with it, so the gearbox must be completely idle or still for the gears to be switched.

Actually, in order to get gears to mesh properly, both the mating gears must be in the same position. This can be accomplished by running the gears at the same speed, but this does take some understanding of how a gear box operates.

Unskilled drivers will have extreme difficulty getting the gearbox to work. More than likely, the gear box will be destroyed in a relatively short period of time, if shifting is considered on the fly.

---------- Post added at 02:12 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:03 PM ----------

And here are the results of the Advance Search for Threads with "Vertical Shaft" in title if you want to do some more research on your own.
http://www.diygokarts.com/vb/search.php?searchid=1991019
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top