Honda GX200 Help

Status
Not open for further replies.

cmartyn

New member
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
This is kind of non go cart related (completely non go cart) but I have an issue and I hope somebody can point me in a direction.

I have a bone stock Honda Gx200 engine and it starts well, I just did a head job on it, new valves etc.

This engine has an electronic throttle. The throttle has 2 speeds 2450 and 3550 RPM. When I set it to 2450 it runs smooth with no load on it. When I kick it up to 3550 (still with no load) it starts to surge and hunt. Not drastic but it is starving for fuel. Spark plug shows lean and putting the choke on about 1/8 to 1/4 will smooth it out. If I put a load on it with the choke open though it gives it a bit more gas and will run smooth.

It has a stock Honda carb with a little motor on it to run the throttle off a computer that senses the engine RPM. It has a 75 main jet and a 45 pilot. I picked up a 78 jet from NR racing, No difference. I also turned the pilot fuel screw out 1/2 turn and that made no difference.

Anyhow, I know you guys are good at carb mods. Any thoughts on how to get it to run smooth at higher RPM's with no load and not sacrifice the way it starts and runs at lower RPM's?
 

mckutzy

Well-known member
Messages
8,353
Reaction score
113
Location
bc, canada
Hello and welcome...

Can you explain more about this electronic throttle you have... And why/what is it for... Pics?

It almost sounds like the gov is set to a lower speed..
 

cmartyn

New member
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Sure..

I didn't want to bore anybody with this but since you asked :). This is an inverter generator. It has two fixed speeds. So, rather than a mechanical governor, it has a computer that monitors the engine speed and opens and closes the throttle with a little motor. From what I can tell, it is not very sophisticated. It can't anticipate a load is about to come or increase or decrease. It simply reacts to engine rpm increases and decreases due to load or, in this case, a lean fuel condition. As for pics, You can't see the computer, it is encased in epoxy. The carb is a Honda Item 21 in this diagram.

http://www.2wheelpros.com/oem-parts/0000-honda-power-equipment-eu3000is-carburetor-assembly.html

When I disconnect that motor the engine stumbles but does not die. The computer is reacting to this stumble by opening the throttle. Very much like a mechanical governor. The engine speeds up and the computer closes the throttle. Since I can correct the engines behavior by choking it, I figured we might be able to tune the carb a bit. Lots of people have this issue. I think Honda did not set this up very well. This is a new carb with fresh fuel too. I have another new carb which is even worse. So we know that the Honda carbs are inconsistent.
 

mckutzy

Well-known member
Messages
8,353
Reaction score
113
Location
bc, canada
How does this clock the engine speed. I couldnt see anything that resembles a pickup for a tach?

And if anything.... does it matter if the choke is on to make it run fine?
Im not too sure if I entirely understand the problem....
 

cmartyn

New member
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
It measures the engine rpm by measuring the frequency of the electrical current on the generator winding.

The problem is this lean running at no load / high rpm. It's so lean it wants to die. Running it with the choke on makes it run too rich when it is under load.

Edit, I guess to equate this to a go cart, You would have the engine on the bench, start it, starts great, idles great, then you slowly open the throttle and somewhere about 3000 rpm it starts to stumble around and you need to keep feathering the throttle so it won't die. Doesn't do it when it is in the cart because it's under load and the throttle is open more but on the bench, it runs like crap.

In this use case for the engine it is an annoyance because it sits there revving up and down all day long.
 
Last edited:

anderkart

Moderator
Messages
6,432
Reaction score
392
Location
Surprise Arizona USA
Have you already checked for an Intake leak? Those carb insulators will slide onto the mounting studs in any orientation, but they'll leak/suck-air when instaled upside down...
 

KartFab

Active member
Messages
3,381
Reaction score
60
Location
Dallas, TX
Sounds like a perfectly normal engine operating as intended. If you don't put a load on the engine and the throttle is wide open, it ramps up the rpms much faster than you would see if it were under load. Because of the extra fast ramp up speed, the governor spring cant compensate fast enough before the engine hits beyond max governed rpms. When the spring finally pulls back the throttle, it has so much kinetic energy, that the throttle actually closes too far, reducing rpms well below governed rpms. At this point, there is little to no force acting on the governor arm spring allowing the throttle butterfly to become wide open, which then allows the engine to ramp up to beyond max goverened rpms due to the lack of load. Cycle repeats itself.

This is called surging/hunting. and can be fixed through either putting the engine under load so it operates like it should, or adjusting the governor arm via the instructions provided in either the factory service manual, and/or the users manual. So the governor kicks in sooner, preventing the back and forth cycling of high/low rpms.

That's assuming your engine has a regular governor on it that operates independently of the throttle mechanism you have there.

So if what I said above is completely irrelevant, just ignore it. Probably is.

So you keep saying lean condition. Im no expert, but a lean condition can be read by the plug, and is independent of throttle position provided your fuel delivery and jetting is correct....

Have a look at the plug to see if it really is leaning out, and not something more serious. I was having some serious issues with a honda gx390, that was experiencing loss of power at higher rpms only to find out that the cylinder wall was shot, and needed to be bored out.

It all happens to us, and this could be preaching to the choir, but have you actually cleaned out your fuel tank, fuel line filter, fuel line, passages in carb, removed jet, removed emulsion tube, and cleaned out the holes in them? Are you really really really sure that identical new carburetors are the source of variation? You first say that you change jets on it, with no difference, then you say you have new ones that perform differently?

AND FINALLY
You make some very confusing statements about how the throttle is actually being operated. You first say it is by computer, then you say you have to feather it? I'm all sorts of confused.
 

cmartyn

New member
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
As for feathering the throttle, I was talking hypothetically about how this engine would operate on a bench as an analogy.

There is no mechanical governor. No springs or arms, so forget all that jazz. It was replaced by a motor run by a computer. The electronic speed control system is completely run by an embedded chip. I do not have any insight into the programming of it though. There is a mechanical dampener in-between the motor and the throttle. It is a stiff spring about the size of a pilot screw spring. If I disconnect that motor from the system and open the throttle by hand, at about 3000 rpm it stumbles, at 3500 it wants to die.

With the motor connected, the motor reacts to this stumbling the same way a mechanical governor would, it opens the throttle, the engine speeds up, it closes the throttle, the engine slows down exactly the same as idle hunting but it reacts much faster than the mechanical governor and does not overshoot as much.

The result is this annoying Up / Down speed. I have a video of it.

It sounds much worse in person than in the video.


EU3000is Running

https://onedrive.live.com/?authkey=...!117677&parId=6EC6669209D370A1!117675&o=OneUp

Yes, we have examined the cylinder etc. There is tons of power. I can load it right up with hardly a groan from it. Leak down test is normal.

All, and I mean all of the fuel system is new except for the tank which was cleaned with acetone.

This is normal operation for this engine. I want to hop it up so it doesn't run so lean it high RPM's when not under load. I really thought the bigger jet would cure it since it happens at higher RPM's.
 

cmartyn

New member
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Yep..

Have you already checked for an Intake leak? Those carb insulators will slide onto the mounting studs in any orientation, but they'll leak/suck-air when instaled upside down...

Yes, the insulator on this can only go one way, it sits on a firewall like plate and picks up the ignition cable. A bit of a chore. I sprayed some wiener dick in there, it just runs off. I can't use ether because inside the cabinet there is too much air blowing around and you get an inconclusive result.

---------- Post added at 09:35 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:34 AM ----------

Have you read the plug though?

Of course, even though we are using oxygenated low lead fuel, I used this old witchdoctor test. It is white as a ghost, just the way the EPA likes them.
 

KartFab

Active member
Messages
3,381
Reaction score
60
Location
Dallas, TX
Hmm, well... a lot of people end up putting a 37 or 38 jet in their performance engines, and a gx140 emulsion tube for a better fuel signal at the Venturi. That might make it too rich though.
 

mckutzy

Well-known member
Messages
8,353
Reaction score
113
Location
bc, canada
Off hand it almost seams like there is an electrical problem, either with the board, the throttle control actuator, or a few others...
I'm assuming this is new, why not take it to an authorized dealer to get it looked at..
 

cmartyn

New member
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Ok, Ill try and be more clear.

I will try and be more clear. This is a design / engineering problem. Honda makes them like this.

To be fair, some of them do not do this. Those would be the brand new ones operated in the summertime at sea level. Deviate from that and they warble.

So that's where we are at. Some units are worse than others.

I have had people tell me that there's does not do this and yet they all of a sudden notice it when I ask for a video.

I don't know, it's like a pressure washer, when you shut off the gun, that engine was not designed to run without a load. As soon as the pump bypass kicks in the engine goes crazy lean and will overheat and blow up if you leave them like that too long.
 

mckutzy

Well-known member
Messages
8,353
Reaction score
113
Location
bc, canada
Idk... Run a large light to balance the load, or turn it off only for when you need it....

What's the geny for anyways? ... Maybe another better powerplant..
 

cmartyn

New member
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Most people run RV's on these. So, it keeps the AC on / Fridge.. TV etc. Most of the time it just idles. They get hot, the exhaust valves melt into the heads and after about 1000 hours its cooked. If you run them on propane they will go 10,000 hours. I will mess with the jet / nozzle a bit then and see if anything helps. Seems kind of dumb. 3 speeds would fix it but then you can't sell that many generators I guess.

Thanks for looking BTW..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top