clutch question???

Status
Not open for further replies.

chasgas

New member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
hey, new here. bought a sears/murray go cart less motor. got the jack shaft with driver pulley (adjusts) but no centrifugal clutch. my question is "will a tensioner type clutch work with the variable driver"?

thanks,

chas
 

kevbo22

Member
Messages
347
Reaction score
0
Location
Colorado
I think what you are saying is you have a driver and no driven unit for a TC setup. If thats the case you can get a driven uint on ebay:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/30-SERIES-T...4d332d9&pid=100005&rk=2&rkt=6&sd=331284441220
The way you worded it however also kinda makes me think that you in fact have the driven unit already on your jackshaft and you actually need a driver.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/30-Series-T...ash=item5423fc01ab:g:F5kAAOSwBw5XQ2RJ&vxp=mtr

I am also assuming you are talking about a 30 series with 3/4 and 5/8 shafts.
Hope it helps a little.
 

chasgas

New member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
hey

shaft is 1". i have the "expandable pulley" on the jack shaft (called a variable driver pulley i believe). i do not have the centrifugal pulley that should go on the motor. it does have a jack shaft that runs to the axle using gears and chain.

i'd rather not buy a centrifugal clutch pulley but i'm not sure if a tensioner type clutch setup will work with the "expandable pulley" on the jack shaft??? i presume it will but better to ask before investing the time to build a tensioner (a third pulley that tightens/loosens the drive belt between motor and jack shaft)..........

many riding lawn mowers used belt drive with a tensioner clutch but they also had transmissions not variable drives like carts or snowmobiles........

thank you for any insight,

chas
 

chasgas

New member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
sorry but you either don't understand the question or you didn't take the time to read???

can i put a plain old pulley on my motor, build a tensioner type clutch setup, drive the variable pulley on the jack shaft and it will work as it was designed (just as it would with the centrifugal clutch that again, i do not want)?

thanks,

chas
 

kevbo22

Member
Messages
347
Reaction score
0
Location
Colorado
What we are saying is we (or at least me) dont think you have a centrifugal clutch, but half of a torque converter.
 

Poboy kartman

Senior Moments Member
Messages
12,461
Reaction score
73
Location
White Settlement Texas
sorry but you either don't understand the question or you didn't take the time to read???

can i put a plain old pulley on my motor, build a tensioner type clutch setup, drive the variable pulley on the jack shaft and it will work as it was designed (just as it would with the centrifugal clutch that again, i do not want)?

thanks,

chas

OK....NO!!!! You don't understand the answer....we told you what you NEED. If we need to lay it out to you...NO!!!! Torque converters use different belts than lawnmower pulleys....get it?
 

chasgas

New member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
well, po boy has an answer. thanks so much. in the one day here reading various threads i've noticed your repeated manner of dealing with members. i'm more than three times the age of the average member here so bullies and their tactics have little to no effect on me.

again, thanks but no centrifugal clutch for me.

i'll simply pull the variable pulley and run two regular pulleys *if* my approach doesn't work. being told it can't work leaves me wondering why?

in my humble opinion, a tensioner type pulley clutch is a much better system than a centrifugal clutch for my granddaughters cart as well as the average carter. she's only 5 with no races in her immediate future.

thanks for any other insight,

chas

keep in mind a tensioner clutch has one bearing that needs to be maintained, very little to go wrong and very easily built.
 

Poboy kartman

Senior Moments Member
Messages
12,461
Reaction score
73
Location
White Settlement Texas
You sir...are a GENIUS....Totally bastardize a decent cart....probably spend more in time and money than the proper part will cost.....are too ignorant and hardheaded toeven realize what a TC does....and you want to give a 5 year old a lever she has to pull to stop the kart....

You're not just old....you're senile!!!!
 

OzFab

Well-known member
Messages
15,615
Reaction score
76
Location
Warwick Qld, Australia
well, po boy has an answer. thanks so much. in the one day here reading various threads i've noticed your repeated manner of dealing with members.

Poboy may be a little brash but, he doesn't have a habit of supplying incorrect info; also, keep in mind, you attacked (for lack of a better term) him first by saying he wasn't reading you post; he did read your post, it was you who didn't understand the post after yours...


i'm more than three times the age of the average member here so bullies and their tactics have little to no effect on me.

Which would put you in you 90's because, although there are some younger members here, the majority of the long term, frequent members are around 40...

There are no bullies here, they are dealt with swiftly by the admin team...

Likewise, WE don't tend to tolerate those who ask for advice/help & then not only ignore our advice but, flat out tell us we're wrong; that's considered arrogant; if you know better than us, why are you asking for our advice/help?

again, thanks but no centrifugal clutch for me.

No one has even mentioned a centrifugal clutch...

Once again, what you have is one of two clutches which, together, connected by a specific belt, makes a torque converter...

Did you get all that?
 

chancer

ɔ ɥ ɐ u ɔ ǝ ɹ
Messages
9,358
Reaction score
97
Location
COMFORT, TEXAS
Wow This guy is old! 3 times the average age of 39 makes him 117yrs old!
Or I mean Dead!

http://www.diygokarts.com/vb/showthread.php?t=33953
Of 26 members surveyed^ We also have a combined wisdom of 1,023 years!
and this list includes a couple of teenagers! Punks bringing down our average
We could have made this guy 123... Still dead though!
 

chasgas

New member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
when i signed up yesterday this is what your site sent:

As forums go, DIYGK is as chilled out as you are going to get. There are very few rules, but we enforce the ones that we do have pretty strictly. This is to keep the forum family orientated. Most of our members are below the age of 20, and we want to keep the forum clean in need of an update?

that would put me in my 60's with nearly 40 years of building custom cars and trucks. fabrication, engine rebuilding, welding, electronics obd to present day, etc.

mod: all the links and advise have told me i need to purchase the other half of the torque drive which in my head is a type of "centrifugal clutch", is it not? you say it's not but it looks as though it basically works in the same manner but this is certainly not my area of expertise.

kevbo22 yes, that's a tensioner type clutch setup which neither ruins a cart and can easily be hooked to a foot pedal just as the manual car you may drive. imagine if the rear pulley is the variable type and the belt is a tc v belt. would it perform?

mod: the responses lead me to believe that only kevbo22 actually read the question or maybe understood it. could i have been clearer (?), probably and for that i apologize.

po boy says it can't work because of the tc belt but i have two snowmobile belts running my compressor so i know a tc belt works on regular pulleys. is the tc belt these carts use so much different? it is a v belt type?

in a couple of hours i can put a tensioner in and test my theory. if it works i'll take time to share some pics. several grand kids from 5-9 have their fingers crossed... i'm shooting for less than 10 mph for the little one and 15-20 mph for the older guy. an adjustable stop on the throttle rod is what comes to mind.

if you're going to tell me something can or can not work, back it up with facts. i do not accept "some anonymous poster simply typing the word yes or no". read the thread, i told no one they were wrong, the misunderstanding is the tc drive pulley that mounts on the motor which i erroneously call a centrifugal clutch although i see very little difference in the two. one squeezes a belt as rpm increases and the other spins out "friction brakes" as rpm increases. both centrifugal and both clutches in my humble opinion.

thanks,

chas



overall, you have a nice website here with the majority of posters (that i've read) showing respect to and sharing knowledge with those less experienced. good luck to you...............................
 

bob58o

SuckSqueezeBangBlow
Messages
9,646
Reaction score
1,866
Location
Chicago-town USA
I don't think a regular Pulley with tensioner will work very well.
Your gear ratio will change depending on the amount of tension.

The TC DRIVEN UNIT you have on the jackshaft works in conjunction with a TC DRIVER UNIT.

As the DRIVER unit closes on the belt (as RPMs increase), the belt rides higher on the DRIVER UNIT. This pulls the belt tighter and in turns opens up the DRIVEN UNIT on the Jackshaft.


I think two fixed (non-variable) pulleys might work with a tensioner, but would waste 20% of your torque.
http://www.bmikarts.com/pdf/comet_40series.pdf
 

Attachments

  • tc GEAR.jpg
    tc GEAR.jpg
    35.9 KB · Views: 1

itsid

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,563
Reaction score
261
Location
Ruhrpott [Germany]
Well we certainly have members under 20.. we have mebers that are not yet considered teenagers..

That messsage you got is likely somewhat out of date considering the "most of our members are"
it should now read "Some of our members are..."
Frankly the POINT of the message is: "do not swear"
And that's still valid.

Aaanyways...
you might have some knowledge.. okay, that's good.
You will certainly not have anything close to our COMBINED knowledge though,
since that is literally impossible.
That's the whole deal about forums.. combined knowledge.. you can't beat that as an individual.

Anyways,
to your problem...
You asked a question that without exact details is hard to answer perfectly correct ont he first go.
What exact part is on your jackshaft (we would need a pic to identify it... descriptions no matter how good will cover several types of driven pulleys)
kevbo assumed a series 30 since that is most common.. and if it indeed is.. it's the correct answer.
could be a different style TC but is still is a Torque Converter for sure
(comet 20, 30 or 40.. 770 790 cat 99.... boring endless list ended prematurely here)

And yes.. a driver unit of any TC works because of centrifugal forces (centripetal if you're going to nitpick on physical terminology)
And yes.. it clutches as well as variates so you have a zero speed on idle engine speed.
True!

It is still NOT considered a centrifugal clutch; not because that is not describing it's function, but because a centrifugal clutch is a term used for -well- centrifugal clutches already, and thus it can be misleading terminology.
it's called a TC Driver unit or Driver Pulley.
It ALSO variates it's active pulley diameter based on the centrifugal force and counteracting forces of the driven unit.which cannot be done with a cent clutch (neither belt nor chain)


just to be as unambiguous as possible.

No, you cannot run a driven unit with a fixed sheave pulley, (at one point it'll open up and slip)
you MUST connect it to a driver with a tc-specific belt. no way around it.
(well no way that will work properly in the end that is)

Sure you can now just assume any of us is not half as smart as you are...
but even if that's true.. we're now 6.. and combined we're three times as smart as you (see.. combined knowledge is great)

So, if you want to do it correctly, post a pic of your driven unit, let us identify it..
in case kevbo's first guess was not perfect, we can link you to the Driver you need and you end up with a well working kart transmission.
Or you can do whatever you felt was a good idea before you asked, then fail and grief come back and start over first...

your choice, but ask yourself what's a wise decision to make.

Again a tensioner type pulley (lawnmower and such) will NOT work with any variable diameter pulley on the other end, not for long nor reliably that is.

here's why... you tension the belt so it's in good contact with the driven... the kart runs,
all is fine.. you come to an incline (say you go up a hill, or try to just climb a curb or something) the torque needed to do so is greater than the torque needed to run a flat paved road.. sooo the rear wheel will work AGAINST your driven pulley (tries to stop it)..
Now it's a battle of forces... the spring that keeps it's sheaves together vs the friction building up..
the path of least resistance will win.. chances are the spring loses and just opens up the sheaves enough to release all friction... engine revs, belt smokes, kart stops.
...and you lost!

If you want to stick with belts...
Two fixed, or two matching variable pulleys.. everything else is dumb. (sorry, but it is!)
feel free to test it if you wish.. but it's on you to prove US wrong, not the other way around! It's you who disagrees with common sense

Also.. NEVER use a throttle stop to limit speed with a TC or cent clutch
both need a certain rpm at which it fully locks.. and that must be met in order to not ruin the clutch itself or the belt.
Luckily. a series 30 TC can be had with an optional speed limiting weightset
http://www.gokartsupply.com/speedr.htm

And to use that would be the smartest move.

gear the kart to the 20mph for the bigger kid, then use the weights for the smaller one,
to limit the speed.

'sid
 

chasgas

New member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
bob58o itsid thanks for your time, knowledge and the "facts" i was looking for. i have to agree with both of you that mixing one half of a torque system to a regular type pulley would be far less than acceptable. it came with the cart and i thought/hoped somehow i could make it work.

throttle stop will work fine with the simple, cheap, virtually maintenance free system i've described.


note: finished college in 1974 and moved out. stepfather immediately bought craftsman riding mower as he quickly learned the push mower i had to use was like work. ha, ha. it was belt driven using the system shown in kev's illustration. the clutch worked smooth and worked flawlessly. i still have that 1974 craftsman and used it on several rental properties i owned plus my own lawn right up to 2000 or so. the clutch works as good as ever to this day. never broke or required parts (clutch). it was good on belts too. i'd ask you if a tc or cent would match that service but no need.

i understand this is apples and oranges for those of you with modified machines, racers, etc. i'm sharing this for those who play in the dirt and don't want to spend $ on your clutch system and belts. on some other go kart sites i've visited several of the regular posters praise this system. try it before you condemn it. or not!

they say there's a 20% loss in power and i can adapt.

again, thank you gentlemen.........................

chas

if i've got this right a tc systems motor component moves out at idle and squeezes in under rpm. this causes the belt to the outer extreme of the pulley (under power) which raises the gear ratio. i believe the opposite happens in the jack shaft tc component. the belt is at the extreme outer portion of the pulley at rest and actually gets pulled into the pulley as the rpm goes up which raises the gear ratio. i believe the movement in both pulleys compliments each other and is required for optimum performance which i knew from the get-go my idea would never achieve. later.....................
 

itsid

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,563
Reaction score
261
Location
Ruhrpott [Germany]
A TC will lose at least 20% of the engine power during transmission..
(as any belt driven system will due to a lack of force fitted connections between a belt and a smooth sheave)
That's why racers do prefere chains..
The TC as opposed to a fixed pulley system can make up for that by providing a variable gear ratio (more torque at take off) that's what it's designed for..
mower don't have / don't need that.. they come with transaxles or gearboxes anyways... karts don't usually.

Anyways, it's not a question of "IF" a tensioner type clutch would work..
millions of ride on mowers have proven it will..
it's a question of if that's the easiest and cheapest way of making it work.
And the simple answer to that is NO .. it's not.

Okay let's compare the two..
you have everything but the driver .. for let's assume it's a series 30 (again that's most common)
http://www.ebay.com/itm/30-Series-T...-Bore-Replaces-Comet-219554-USA-/152125735015

fifty bucks.. install that to your engine, add the belt... done.. works!

You'd rather go with a tensioner style.. cool..
you'll need a pulley and although I can't seem to find a good example.. I'm sure a 1" bore small pulely will be availabel.. for around 10-15 bucks... right?
saved 40 bucks, right.. Now you need another idler pulley for the tensioner mechanism.. in fact you need two more pulley.. an Idler and the driven side (since the TC driven is of no use)
another small one (again 10-15 bucks) and a bigger one (let's call it 20 bucks...[most I found are above 30 though... nevermind]) for the jackshaft you have
added up you have 40-50 bucks as well.
AND you need to fab a lever and linkage system to engage disengage the idler/tensioner, maybe add a belt catch to prevent the belt from jumping off the pulleys..
and with steel and bushings, bolts and time you quickly spend more then the fifty needed...
PLUS you spend another three and a half days in your garage fabbing it up, fixing minor or major issues when the kids yould just plow the lawn with the kart.
even if you have enough scrap metal and parts laying around.. welding wire alone will at least cost you another dollar ;)

So.. yeah.. viable? sure.. easiest, quickest, cheapest? surely not.

Keep in mind that most of us also want to make the most cost effective kart possible as well..
we're cheap at times as much as anybody else.. we search for bargains and we use chinese clone parts and engines (predators for example) where we can and when think it's feasible.

just sayin'

'sid
 

bob58o

SuckSqueezeBangBlow
Messages
9,646
Reaction score
1,866
Location
Chicago-town USA
LOL.

Now I want to try to make a manual shiftable trans using a standard pulley, a TC driven pulley, and an idler pulley on a lever.

Pull the lever to engage.
Pull a little harder to shift?
Spring connecting the idler pulley and the lever?
Finding the right spring might be tricky.
Challenges are fun. For testing purposes only?

Yes I DID READ why it won't work!!!


More GAB Less KISS!

LOL. Hmmmm????
 

chasgas

New member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
sid, we're just going to have to agree that we disagree.

i just looked at that driver to see if i could put a bolt through it and convert it to a regular pulley. i notice one of the castings with the
"shoes" (sorry, non-karter here) hooked to the pulley is broken. planned obsolescence strikes yet again.

sid, what is the average (best of worst, worst of best) life of a tc unit? all things considered. i'd guess the front half at the motor gets the most abuse?

i drew up a diagram this morning: imagine you push the brake and it engages the clutch, as you push down further you apply the brakes. both on one pedal, same as the old craftsman mower. not that complicated considering the tensioner can be positioned with plenty of room for travel. mild steel round stock could easily be fashioned to fit around the drive pulleys to keep the belt from jumping off.

lastly, there are several examples of a tensioner type belt system on various kart sites but i'll certainly share a pic or two when i get to it. i'm up to my elbows finishing a 62 vw meyers manx type dune buggy. put it on the road the other day. has to be ready for a car show this coming weekend. too much work, too little time.

chas
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top