Need help choosing engine

Status
Not open for further replies.

corona44

New member
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
I want to start a pretty "different" type of project, instead of the go kart that I was going to build. I want to buy a mobility scooter (http://www.easymobilityco.com/ctm_hs-580_mobility_scooter.htm) and add either an electric or gas engine.

I want it to go 40-50mph. I cannot sacrifice speed.

Here are some of my concerns...

Which would be cheaper (gas or electric?) Which would be cheaper to run/maintain? About how much would each cost, to get it to go that fast? Which would be easier to build?

Can you guys suggest me what engine I should use? Would this work, if I use gas? It's a 16hp 4 stroke. http://www.maxtool.com/us/products/XP16HPE.asp

Lastly, do you think it would be possible to somehow register this as a custom vehicle for local use (small streets and neighborhoods only)? I live in California. What would I have to add to this to make that possible, or is it just too much to be possible? I'm fine if this isn't possible, it would just be cool if it was. Cheap and easy transportation :D

Thanks.
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
50MPH on a mobility scooter? Holy crap. How's your life insurance situation?

Anyways, I think it's cheaper to run gas, but my electrical knowledge is limited. AFAIK, a DC motor, controller, and battery bank is going to cost more, and more still if you end up having to replace batteries after awhile.

Now- I think you can achieve the speed, but it will be hard. You're going to have small tires, which is a limiting factor. I think a CVT is in order, but you don't likely need all 16hp. You could probably do it with an ungoverned 11-13hp, and Comet 40 CVT. (or clone of same).

The problem is that gearing is a trade-off, even with a CVT. If you're geared to go quite fast, the low end will probably be sensitive and perhaps tough to finesse. Less so with a CVT, but still likely. On a mobility scooter, I would think you would want some finesse for the sidewalks.

On the other hand, if you want the ability to drive yerself right into the WalMart and get yer groceries, you'd better go electric- or you're walking into the store...

Is your mobility limited?

We had a nice older fella on here that was working on a very similar project. Quite unfortunately, the build was never completed because he passed. RIP Wall Gator.

By the way- Welcome to the forum!

EDIT- here's a thought- get past all the gearing woes with a transmission or transaxle from a lawn tractor. A transaxle may be the better choice. Compact (compared to a seperate tranny and axle) a good range of gears, and vertical shaft engines tend to be cheaper. You might even be able to save the budget by scoring a running lawn tractor and gutting it.
 

corona44

New member
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Gas it is. It will be used outdoors (small streets, maybe a bit of dirt) 99% of its life, I just wasn't sure if electric would be more beneficial. To be honest, I am very new to engines in general, so I don't know about most of what you're saying. I tried to find the Comet 40 but I can't figure out where to buy it.

I don't like to be spoon-fed, but I just don't know enough about these things to figure it out myself. I wouldn't know what is compatible with what, and things like that. Can you give me a little more advice now that I know I'm going to use a gas engine?

As for the gearing, what do you mean the low end would be sensitive? Sorry but I'm all-around a bit confused.
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
Basically, with high gearing- try to think of it like this-

You've got one inch of stroke in the gas pedal, which will take you to 50MPH. You want to try to drive at 10MPH in a tight spot. You're feathering the first 0.2" of gas pedal, hit it a bit too hard, and off the end of the loading dock you go! LOL

There's a bit more to it than that, but it's a basic picture.

Stick around a bit, somebody can point you in the right direction for a Comet 40 or chinese copy of one. I don't tend to buy things from your typical (American) go kart parts retailers.
 

corona44

New member
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Thanks for the analogy, I understand a bit better now. I'll keep looking on here and locally for a Comet 40. Do you think that engine will be fine? The price on it is good with me, and it seems like a good deal. It even has electric start :)

Edit: I want to lean towards a lower ratio for better acceleration with this. That is correct, isn't it?
 

OzFab

Well-known member
Messages
15,615
Reaction score
76
Location
Warwick Qld, Australia
Gas it is. It will be used outdoors (small streets, maybe a bit of dirt) 99% of its life, I just wasn't sure if electric would be more beneficial. To be honest, I am very new to engines in general, so I don't know about most of what you're saying. I tried to find the Comet 40 but I can't figure out where to buy it.

Glad you decided on gas coz here's another hurdle:
Electric: you run out of juice, recharge takes hours
Gas: you run out of juice, refill the tank & you're off in minutes :D

I don't like to be spoon-fed, but I just don't know enough about these things to figure it out myself. I wouldn't know what is compatible with what, and things like that. Can you give me a little more advice now that I know I'm going to use a gas engine?

Good, coz we don't like doing it,:roflol: it can get very frustrating for us; a bit of common sense goes a long way. Having said that, we can talk you through pretty much any situation.

As for the gearing, what do you mean the low end would be sensitive? Sorry but I'm all-around a bit confused.

He's referring to acceleration. There's three ways to gear... well, anything:
1. quick take off; the trade off is top speed is not that impressive
2. Top speed; & your acceleration sux. You'll go really fast but it'll take you a week to reach that speed.
3. Balanced: you get decent acceleration & a decent top speed
 

corona44

New member
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
He's referring to acceleration. There's three ways to gear... well, anything:
1. quick take off; the trade off is top speed is not that impressive
2. Top speed; & your acceleration sux. You'll go really fast but it'll take you a week to reach that speed.
3. Balanced: you get decent acceleration & a decent top speed

Could you have it be balanced, get a slightly stronger engine, and have the best of both worlds?
 

corona44

New member
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
When saying the engine is overkill, remember that the original cart weight is 200 pounds. Remove about 30, I guess, because we're removing the electric motor/batteries. Add 80 lbs for the engine, 10 more to be safe, and finally 130-150 for the rider. That is roughly 400 pounds being hauled. It just seems like you'd need a big engine to do that.

Plus I'd like that decent acceleration and good top speed ;)

Not trying to sound like I know more than you, I'm just explaining why I chose that engine in the first place.
 

OzFab

Well-known member
Messages
15,615
Reaction score
76
Location
Warwick Qld, Australia
Could you have it be balanced, get a slightly stronger engine, and have the best of both worlds?

Not exactly. With a stronger engine you could have a slightly higher ratio (lower numbers) Let me explain:
The majority if industrial engines (Honda GX, predator, B&S, etc) all have a maximum RPM of 3600. So, using the same gearing, you'll get the same top speed from a 5hp as you would from a 15hp, the difference is you'll reach it a lot quicker with the 15hp due to the increased torque (turning effort).

FYI: Horsepower = RPM x Torque. If both engines have the same max RPM, you have to assume the difference is in the torque rating.

Now, let's use a higher ratio. Again, the top speed will be the same with both but, the 15hp will get there whereas the 5hp will struggle due to lack of torque
 

OzFab

Well-known member
Messages
15,615
Reaction score
76
Location
Warwick Qld, Australia
Expensive worms &, if you know very little about engines, bad worms.

Basically, the governor prevents catastrophic failure; remove the governor & you have to upgrade the internals to prevent this happening
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
Stronger engine allows higher gearing for better speed with respectable acceleration. Governor removal allows higher RPM- which allows the ability to reach higher speed OR reduce gearing for better acceleration and still hit good top speed, or both.
 

corona44

New member
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
I see. Well, I guess I will post later once I get a scooter and engine. Hopefully it won't be too long before then :wai:
 

Jcotz

...wasn't there
Messages
374
Reaction score
1
Location
NY
Not exactly. With a stronger engine you could have a slightly higher ratio (lower numbers) Let me explain:
The majority if industrial engines (Honda GX, predator, B&S, etc) all have a maximum RPM of 3600. So, using the same gearing, you'll get the same top speed from a 5hp as you would from a 15hp, the difference is you'll reach it a lot quicker with the 15hp due to the increased torque (turning effort).

FYI: Horsepower = RPM x Torque. If both engines have the same max RPM, you have to assume the difference is in the torque rating.

Now, let's use a higher ratio. Again, the top speed will be the same with both but, the 15hp will get there whereas the 5hp will struggle due to lack of torque

Almost all of this is correct, but the correct formula for hp is actually hp=(Torque*Rpm's
)/5252. Just to clear that up and prevent any misinformation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top