Piston rings for GX110

Status
Not open for further replies.

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
:iagree:

If the engine is already apart, the rings shouldn't cost too much, as the labour's there already.

If not, go ahead and run it, and do the rings when you have the budget.

The "no compression test" thing is driving me nuts.
How do you properly and completely assess an engine when you cannot/will not compare to specs? This is a professional mechanic, not just some dude with a Tonka screwdriver, right?
 

landuse

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
18,803
Reaction score
611
Location
Pietermaritzburg, South Africa
This is a professional mechanic we are talking about. They are the certified Honda dealers in town. I have always had an impression that they are a little shady though.

When I ran the engine before, it did smoke a little, but not excessively. If I do a conversion to dollars, the rings are going to cost me about $32. It probably sounds like a lot to you, but here that is about normal.
 

robbie

New member
Messages
857
Reaction score
9
Location
Osceola, Missouri
If your engine was smoking a little bit there's nothing wrong with putting in new rings. But you can run an engine and have fun on a go kart until it has virtually no compression left at all, if you want to. If you want to save money in the future, find another engine somewhere for cheap if you can, and take it apart yourself. Small engines are very simple. You'll find that there's nothing to it, especially if you can get a manual for the engine, and get advice from other enthusiasts.

Squeezing extra money out of people is a longstanding tradition among professional mechanics. The usual way it's done is to replace parts that are not fully used up yet. It's hard to argue with them because all they're telling you to do is restore your equipment to new condition. Even honest mechanics do this from time to time because some customers who don't know better will demand that something be rebuilt to factory specs even when it's not broken.

When I lived in the city and didn't have a lot of tools I used to get my muffler work done at a shop which also had a state inspection license. They never tried to rip me off because I mentioned to them that I'm an airplane mechanic, so they knew that I knew what was going on. But I tried sending my wife there a couple of times when I was busy doing something else, and they always gave her the "woman treatment". They tried selling her parts that weren't needed, and the cost was always a lot higher. On those occasions, I simply went back with the same car the next day, and they gave me the real deal and pretended that my wife hadn't been there the day before.
 

redsox985

Active member
Messages
4,092
Reaction score
12
Location
PA
This crap just happened to my mom. There was a voluntary recall on Acura MDX's from a specific time because the transmission software would sometimes cause irregularities that caused the car to shimmy at certain speeds. She took it in, got the update and then twice in the next week her car wouldn't start. AAA came out, tested her battery and it was all good. They jumped her and she was fine.

The second time, we were skiing, went to leave and the car wouldn't do a thing. She tried a few more times and it went. We got home and popped the hood. After checking all connections, we found that the - terminal on the battery was so loose you could slide it off by hand. We tightened it down and have been fine since. We suspect the dealer loosened this to get us back in the shop to charge us for labor and a new battery. This is the reason why my dad only trusts 2 or 3 small shops to do car work for us.
 

devino246

Official DIYGK Chem Nerd
Messages
3,856
Reaction score
17
Location
Lynchburg, VA
This crap just happened to my mom. There was a voluntary recall on Acura MDX's from a specific time because the transmission software would sometimes cause irregularities that caused the car to shimmy at certain speeds. She took it in, got the update and then twice in the next week her car wouldn't start. AAA came out, tested her battery and it was all good. They jumped her and she was fine.

The second time, we were skiing, went to leave and the car wouldn't do a thing. She tried a few more times and it went. We got home and popped the hood. After checking all connections, we found that the - terminal on the battery was so loose you could slide it off by hand. We tightened it down and have been fine since. We suspect the dealer loosened this to get us back in the shop to charge us for labor and a new battery. This is the reason why my dad only trusts 2 or 3 small shops to do car work for us.

Dealers are usually the least shady, at least in my experiences. They probably just forgot to tighten it down.
 

Badot

New member
Messages
677
Reaction score
2
Here's my experience with dealers/service places... just a warning, it's a bit of a rant and goes off topic at some points too, so no need to read if you don't feel like it. Also, this is just my experience with a single person... there are many more, all but one bad, but this guy takes the cake:

My dad has a 'guy' (at a dealership) that my family takes all of our cars to and always get suckered into buying things. My dad kinda has the "Ohhhh this guy is finding things wrong with the car and keeping us safe" kinda mindset, I guess. At one point the minivan (which is 'mine' (I'm sure we all know how that goes) now, but wasn't at the time) got a clogged fuel filter. Car wouldn't start until you cycled the fuel pump on and off a few times, it'd run for a bit, stall out again... classic clogged filter. I was driving it at the time, and by the time I had gotten it home the problem seemed to have resolved itself. Parents still wanted to take it to the shop, and my mom even said the check engine light turned off as she was driving to the shop, yet the mechanic still somehow managed to pull trouble codes from it, and said the 'computer' and the camshaft position sensor needed to be replaced. They charged $500 for the 'computer', and $30ish for the sensor. Total bill was $2000, so I guess the 'labor' was through the roof as well. Anyways, I checked it out later... none of the control boxes (what I call the ECU, cabin computer, etc) had been replaced, as evidenced by the undisturbed dust/particles on them and their connectors. Also, the gas tank was nearly empty, after it was taken in with a half tank. So maybe they changed the fuel pump (which has the filter built in) in which case the missing fuel would be acceptable, had they said something about checking/changing/whatevering it, however, they didn't, and that's 200 miles worth of gas. Completely unacceptable.

Next up came the oil change. I was going to do it myself. I got the car jacked up, warmed up, and I had a pot under the oil pan. I put my socket wrench onto the plug, and it wouldn't move. So, I moved up to my 10" vice grip monkey wrench (like a monkey wrench but the jaw clamps down... essentially gives you a perfectly sized wrench, which I had personally tested another one to the point of failure to confirm that the jaws will not spread)... still can't turn it, and can't fit a breaker bar down there. So, I leave the wrench clamped to the plug, about perpendicular with the ground, tie paracord to the loop on the end of the handle, go to the side of the car, and pull (and yes, I was trying to turn in the correct direction). When I got to what would be my estimate of somewhere around 100 lbs of force on it, the wrench turned, and I fell on my back end. Like I said, the wrench turned. I went back under the car, and attempted to turn it by hand, and it still wouldn't budge. I pulled the wrench off. While the wrench had turned, the plug had not, and replacing two corners of the plug head were corners round enough you could swear were meant to be that way, save for the top of the head bulging outwards and the shiny finish. At this point I agreed to let my dad take it to the dealership if he did two things: ask him if the plug was on there very tight, and have him hand tighten it when replacing it. Naturally, my dad didn't ask him to hand tighten it, however did ask if it was on there tight, and what he used to get it off. His responses: "no" and "monkey wrench".

Number three: Car went in for tires. Mount, balance, all that good stuff. Long story short: Steering knuckle, or whatever it is that aligns the knuckle is damaged, and now the car pulls left... not horribly, but still requires an annoying (and tiring over time) amount of force to on the wheel to keep the car going straight. The mechanic said (more like blamed it on) it was because you couldn't adjust the toe angle... which is true, but wouldn't need adjusting had the knuckle not been damaged.

And just to gripe, all this stacks onto the fact that I'm a fairly new driver (~2 years, been driving on a regular basis for less than 1) in a minivan (horrible acceleration (think merging), spotty brake booster, and the horrendous handling every minivan entails, not to mention getting blown around by wind) so when you throw in the car actively fighting you to pull into incoming traffic with both sides running at 65-80mph... not to sound ungrateful, I mean... well it's not really mine but I didn't pay for it, and my parents help a bit with insurance... but I'm just not happy with it.

Anyways, needless to say, the minivan doesn't go there anymore. To date, I've needed to change the serp. belt, water pump, and idler pulley, flushed the radiator, changed the radiator hoses, and spark plugs (copper ones which looked at least 50k miles old, friend who works on cars said they were the worst he'd ever seen), replaced the instrument cluster (tach motor burned out, parents blamed me, otherwise I wouldn't have bothered), and done the routine maintenance. Yes, all that in less than a year. It wasn't taken good care of, but it seems to be running well now. Just out of curiosity, I got a quote for that and it came out to around $1000 parts, $5000 labor. I paid about $200 and did it all myself in about 5 hours. It still needs a new brake booster, but I don't feel comfortable working on the brakes, and nowhere around here has given me an anywhere near affordable price. E-brake still works though. So yeah, at least in my experience, maintenance shops = run/drive away as fast as you can.
 

robbie

New member
Messages
857
Reaction score
9
Location
Osceola, Missouri
Wow, that's a pretty impressive story. If you want something done right, do it yourself. If you don't do it right, make sure you're learning while you're doing it. Even with mistakes you'll be better off in the long run.

The only things I have done at shops are tires, alignment, and state inspections.
 

landuse

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
18,803
Reaction score
611
Location
Pietermaritzburg, South Africa
I agree with everyone about the ripping off of people. I took my lawn mower in for repairs at this one place and they gave me such an inflated quote that I told them that I don't want the work done. (I need new piston and rings etc.) I took it to another mower repair shop and they quoted me half the price for the same work. Everyone here in town uses the same parts supplier, so it is not as if that was the reason they charged so much. I thought I might as well put in a picture of my mower. I got it from my father who used it for about 10 years until he gave it to me. I have had it for about 5 years now. It runs like a champ. It has a Robin EC10 motor on it.

I really do need to learn how to take motors appart myself. As robbie said, I should buy a cheap motor and take it appart to see how everything works. I am keen to learn, cos I am tired of paying people to do things when I know it probably isn't too hard to do myself.
 

Attachments

  • 241220101501.jpg
    241220101501.jpg
    86.7 KB · Views: 8

landuse

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
18,803
Reaction score
611
Location
Pietermaritzburg, South Africa
Russ: I finally got some pics of the mower you asked for. There is not too much to ID it on the mower, but it is a Robin EC10 motor. Apparently it has gone out of production, but it is a really sturdy little engine. It generally starts first pull, (unless it decides to be temperamental).

I felt like a fool the one day. The guy who cuts my lawn is clueless when it comes to engines, so he tells me the one day that it just died and he can't get it going. So I start pulling and sweating, using starter booster spray, taking the plug out, trying the choke in different positions, and everything else I could think of. I then get the genius idea to check if he had run out of fuel. Guess what....he had!! I could have kicked myself for not checking the most obvious thing. I suppose you learn....
 

Attachments

  • 29012011219.jpg
    29012011219.jpg
    89.4 KB · Views: 2
  • 29012011220.jpg
    29012011220.jpg
    149.7 KB · Views: 2
  • 29012011221.jpg
    29012011221.jpg
    134.2 KB · Views: 3
  • 29012011222.jpg
    29012011222.jpg
    95.2 KB · Views: 2
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top