Will centrifugal clutches allow engine braking?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Toycrusher

New member
Messages
168
Reaction score
0
Location
Deep Deep South Texas
Measured it and I do have a 6" driven unit with the green spring.

I'm a little unclear on the speed calculations. Right now I can hit 23 mph on the gps with a death wish (No suspension, bounces like crazy on smooth asphalt and handles really squirrely, band brakes are more of a placebo than a means of slowing the cart... :smiley_omg::roflol:)

I have 13.5:1 gear ratio, I'm assuming a 10% overdrive on the converter, and a briggs 5.5 rpm governed at 3600 rpm. Doing the math I should be at about 21 mph. Why the extra speed? Maybe the governor is letting the engine rev a bit more? The tires might also be growing in diameter at the higher speeds :huh:

In any case, a couple of my kids power wheels do almost 12 mph, that's a bit too slow. Maybe I'll go with a 48T sprocket instead of 60T. That drops my static reduction to 18:1, and 16.2:1 counting the overdrive for a top speed around 15 mph. The extra gearing should still help quite a bit.

As far as the electric motor, it's rated 2.25 hp, 2400 watts. Throwing those numbers into a calculator I get something between 6 lb/ft and 9 lb/ft of torqe, roughly equivalent to the 5.5hp gas engine. How to gear it becomes a big question mark.

If I used a 12T sprocket it would match engine gearing (well, minus the 3:1 torque converter "low") and should have plenty of torque, but the clutch would also be spinning at engine rpm which Tazmannusa brought up might smoke the bushing pretty quickly.

If I went with a 24t sprocket it would spin at 1/2 engine speed, probably much easier on the bushing, but I don't know if 9:1 reduction would get the big wheels moving either. Since the motor would be wired direct, no throttle controller, engaging the motor at 9:1 would be shooting for an instant 19mph! I dunno if the clutch would slip enough for a smooth and slower start, or if the chain would just pop :mad2: . Geared back at 18:1 it would only be shooting for 10mph but depending on clutch action it could still be a whiplash inducing affair... :huh::huh::huh:
 

Toycrusher

New member
Messages
168
Reaction score
0
Location
Deep Deep South Texas
So thinking more about this... :eek:

I could go 60t with a 12 mph top speed, then remove my governor to gain an additional 1000-1500 rpm. That would put me in the 15 - 18 mph range I want to be at. Hmmm... :stir::devil2:
 

OzFab

Well-known member
Messages
15,615
Reaction score
76
Location
Warwick Qld, Australia
Under power, valve float will kick in at around 5000rpm; however, if we go back to the original topic, with the clutch engaged, running downhill, the engine may exceeds 5000rpm which may cause engine damage...
 

itsid

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,563
Reaction score
261
Location
Ruhrpott [Germany]
I still can't wrap my head around that cent clutch engine breaking completely..

I'm just not sure which of the applied forces will prevail..

A clutch consists of three steps..
the shoes, driven by the engine,
the return spring(s) working against the engine contracting the shoes back to idle;
and the bell fixed to the sprocket and thus the wheels

Now, the engine forces the shoes outwards, overwhelming the springs and slippage of the bell engaging the clutch and moving the kart.
But as soon as the engine stops (throttle released or is cut off)
the engine and the return springs work together to retract the shoes.

IDK if that is enough to cause slippage and/or at which point it'd be enough to cause slippage in the clutch.
But as soon as the clutch slips (even at speed) it will disengage in an instant.

And don't forget, that all mechanical force will always take the least resistive path..
and I guess that'd be slip very early in time (~3000 rpm If I had to make a guess)

Do not forget that all the torque the engine provides is now working against you...
and considering a common engagement speed of 2k rpm... I wouldn't underestimate the power of the return springs either...

*shrugs*
IDK... my best guess is: with a decent gear ratio, you'll not see much engine breaking at all going downhill.

Maybe it also depends on the clutch design..
since some clutches use a design that looks like the engine is actually able to ACTIVELY disengage when it slows down (a unidirectional clutch for example)

Again, I don't know;
but I tend towards "no to not much engine breaking" ;)

'sid
 

Toycrusher

New member
Messages
168
Reaction score
0
Location
Deep Deep South Texas
I still can't wrap my head around that cent clutch engine breaking completely..

I'm just not sure which of the applied forces will prevail..

A clutch consists of three steps..
the shoes, driven by the engine,
the return spring(s) working against the engine contracting the shoes back to idle;
and the bell fixed to the sprocket and thus the wheels

Now, the engine forces the shoes outwards, overwhelming the springs and slippage of the bell engaging the clutch and moving the kart.
But as soon as the engine stops (throttle released or is cut off)
the engine and the return springs work together to retract the shoes.

IDK if that is enough to cause slippage and/or at which point it'd be enough to cause slippage in the clutch.
But as soon as the clutch slips (even at speed) it will disengage in an instant.

And don't forget, that all mechanical force will always take the least resistive path..
and I guess that'd be slip very early in time (~3000 rpm If I had to make a guess)

Do not forget that all the torque the engine provides is now working against you...
and considering a common engagement speed of 2k rpm... I wouldn't underestimate the power of the return springs either...

*shrugs*
IDK... my best guess is: with a decent gear ratio, you'll not see much engine breaking at all going downhill.

Maybe it also depends on the clutch design..
since some clutches use a design that looks like the engine is actually able to ACTIVELY disengage when it slows down (a unidirectional clutch for example)

Again, I don't know;
but I tend towards "no to not much engine breaking" ;)

'sid

I appreciate the help. It was mostly a theoretical question. If I go through with this and use an electric motor for boost on take-off, I wanted to know if the clutch would release the electric motor once the kart was underway and electric power was cut. Still in theoretical terms, At full throttle I could have a clutch speed of 5000 rpm and a motor speed of zero. Or it could stay locked and my 2500 rpm electric motor might come flying apart when the gas engine hits 5000... :popcorn: :mad:
 

ezcome-ezgo

G'me sumthin to write on
Messages
6,032
Reaction score
3,047
Location
Atlanta, GA
I think it depends on the weight of the vehicle and the slope of the hill. Again, my experience is that a with heavy cart (with a "C") and a significant slope, gravity becomes the "engine" and once the shoes are engaged, they will stay that way until a)the slope flattens out, b)the brakes are applied, or c) something breaks.
 

Toycrusher

New member
Messages
168
Reaction score
0
Location
Deep Deep South Texas
Ok, so this project is definitely not dead. I started with changing out my jackshaft input sprocket from 32t to 60t, roughly doubling my gearing from 13:1 to 24:1, not counting torque converter reduction. My goal is to be able to pull wheelies, even if I hit the governor at 10-12 mph...

Got it swapped, barely fits, almost touches converter output sprocket. Got new chain and set length, but I'm really fighting the master link. How are they supposed to be oriented again? My first attempt at running went almost 10' before it spit the master link. I finnesed the sprocket alignment and put it together again, with the clip to the inside of the chain instead of the outside (does it matter?), this time I went a solid 15' before spitting the link and twisting it all up.

What am I doing wrong?
 

Attachments

  • 2016-03-06 17.11.56.jpg
    2016-03-06 17.11.56.jpg
    316 KB · Views: 3
  • 2016-03-06 18.06.00.jpg
    2016-03-06 18.06.00.jpg
    181.1 KB · Views: 2
  • 2016-03-06 17.11.40.jpg
    2016-03-06 17.11.40.jpg
    235.4 KB · Views: 2
  • 2016-03-06 17.10.59.jpg
    2016-03-06 17.10.59.jpg
    264 KB · Views: 3

itsid

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,563
Reaction score
261
Location
Ruhrpott [Germany]
the closed end of the clip should point in the same direction the chain is travelling (i.e front above the axle/jackshaft, back below the axle/js)

if the clip is pointing in- or outboard doesn't matter at all;
as long as it has enough clearance for it to pass without hitting something...

With that amount of torque though, you might want to consider a riveted chain instead
since masterlinks are weaker than "ordinary" links.

But for now I'd say fix the clip to the plate once in place with a drop of loctite (or CA glue) to make sure it doesn't rattle off. (weak clip)
Since by the look of it I assume you first lost the clip, and the plate shortly after before it bent open.

'sid
 

Toycrusher

New member
Messages
168
Reaction score
0
Location
Deep Deep South Texas
Yeah, found my stupid mistake, forgot to slip the plate on before putting the clip... :mad2:

I'm thinking of just assembling the chain without the master link but there's no room to work in that thing and I have to assemble the chain in place. Can't get the chain on if it's already assembled. Any tricks for pressing plates on in tight areas?
 

Toycrusher

New member
Messages
168
Reaction score
0
Location
Deep Deep South Texas
I'll give it a shot, might be able to get vise grips in place and use washers over the pins. If I fail miserably, I'll try the master link again, with the plate...
 

Toycrusher

New member
Messages
168
Reaction score
0
Location
Deep Deep South Texas
Used a c-clamp and a socket and was able to assemble the chain without the master link. I was hoping to pull wheelies with 26:1 ratio apart from the torque converter, but it wasn't to be. It does however climb inclines effortlessly when it used to smoke the belt so overall I'm quite happy
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top