karl
Well-known member
Q. Why do engines need backpressure? Won’t a larger exhaust pipe give my 944’s naturally aspirated engine more power?
A. I’ve always understood that you want to keep the exhaust gases moving, even once you get them out of the cylinder. One thing that will cause the gas to slow down is a sudden decrease in temperature, which is one reason why auto makers don’t try to cool the exhaust manifold. The other thing that can cause a decrease in flow velocity is rapid expansion and turbulence, like going from a small passage (like the exhaust port in the head) to a 6-inch pipe. A smaller-diameter pipe geometry will tend to keep the flow rate up, but it will also lose heat more quickly (less exhaust gas per linear inch of pipe). However, a large pipe will slow the velocity due to expansion. Worse still, the exhaust is constantly cooling from the moment it leaves the cylinder, meaning it’s getting denser and slower. See the problem here? It’s all about compromises. The proper pipe size is going to be influenced by the flow rate (volume rate, which is related to RPM and engine displacement), exhaust velocity (again related to RPM), exhaust temperature (constantly changing, and as high as 2,000&Mac251;F, if I remember right), and undoubtedly an array of other factors. All of this is dependent on the application: is this a street car, a race car, or something in between? Where will the engine spend most of its time? Idle, full throttle, part throttle?
I’ve also heard the thing about back pressure, but I believe that they’re really talking about flow velocities. That is, if you can keep the exhaust gases moving in the exhaust pipe, they will cause a small reduced-pressure area behind the closed exhaust valve, in the exhaust. This happens because the gases have momentum. They move away from the valve, creating a localized reduction in pressure. When the exhaust valve opens, this reduced-pressure zone will help evacuate the burnt gases from the cylinder. Or so the theory goes, as I understand it (two disclaimers there).
The bottom line is that Porsche has probably already considered all this and other factors when sizing the exhaust on the 944. Unless you’re significantly increasing the flow rate, you’re likely to cause more harm than good.
From Warner Technology Consulting
Take a a garden hose and put a specific volume of water thru it. The water pressure in the hose will be a certain value as will the velocity of the water escaping the hose. Now, put that same volume of water thru a firehose. Is the water pressure value in the firehose going to be the same? Also, will the velocity of the water leaving the end of the hose be the same? The answer to both questions is "No".
So, getting back to your question about exhaust piping diameter. If you use too large of a pipe for your engine, exhaust gas velocity will suffer since the exhaust gasses expand and cool too rapidly in the larger pipe, which hurts performance. They slow down because they become more dense as they cool, and the exhaust scavenging becomes very poor. This causes the engine to have to "push" harder to expell the spent gasses, which destroys torque. It's not too little backpressure that causes this. That is a misnomer. I wish people would quit using that term.
Yota Tec .com
So if your straight pipe is to large it gives your engine less power.
A. I’ve always understood that you want to keep the exhaust gases moving, even once you get them out of the cylinder. One thing that will cause the gas to slow down is a sudden decrease in temperature, which is one reason why auto makers don’t try to cool the exhaust manifold. The other thing that can cause a decrease in flow velocity is rapid expansion and turbulence, like going from a small passage (like the exhaust port in the head) to a 6-inch pipe. A smaller-diameter pipe geometry will tend to keep the flow rate up, but it will also lose heat more quickly (less exhaust gas per linear inch of pipe). However, a large pipe will slow the velocity due to expansion. Worse still, the exhaust is constantly cooling from the moment it leaves the cylinder, meaning it’s getting denser and slower. See the problem here? It’s all about compromises. The proper pipe size is going to be influenced by the flow rate (volume rate, which is related to RPM and engine displacement), exhaust velocity (again related to RPM), exhaust temperature (constantly changing, and as high as 2,000&Mac251;F, if I remember right), and undoubtedly an array of other factors. All of this is dependent on the application: is this a street car, a race car, or something in between? Where will the engine spend most of its time? Idle, full throttle, part throttle?
I’ve also heard the thing about back pressure, but I believe that they’re really talking about flow velocities. That is, if you can keep the exhaust gases moving in the exhaust pipe, they will cause a small reduced-pressure area behind the closed exhaust valve, in the exhaust. This happens because the gases have momentum. They move away from the valve, creating a localized reduction in pressure. When the exhaust valve opens, this reduced-pressure zone will help evacuate the burnt gases from the cylinder. Or so the theory goes, as I understand it (two disclaimers there).
The bottom line is that Porsche has probably already considered all this and other factors when sizing the exhaust on the 944. Unless you’re significantly increasing the flow rate, you’re likely to cause more harm than good.
From Warner Technology Consulting
Take a a garden hose and put a specific volume of water thru it. The water pressure in the hose will be a certain value as will the velocity of the water escaping the hose. Now, put that same volume of water thru a firehose. Is the water pressure value in the firehose going to be the same? Also, will the velocity of the water leaving the end of the hose be the same? The answer to both questions is "No".
So, getting back to your question about exhaust piping diameter. If you use too large of a pipe for your engine, exhaust gas velocity will suffer since the exhaust gasses expand and cool too rapidly in the larger pipe, which hurts performance. They slow down because they become more dense as they cool, and the exhaust scavenging becomes very poor. This causes the engine to have to "push" harder to expell the spent gasses, which destroys torque. It's not too little backpressure that causes this. That is a misnomer. I wish people would quit using that term.
Yota Tec .com
So if your straight pipe is to large it gives your engine less power.