where is the QUALITY??

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bluethunder3320

New member
Messages
5,677
Reaction score
39
this is pretty disappointing... never buy a newer B&S engine...

last summer my neighbor had a mower with a (2003) 6.75 OHV briggs on it. the motor would not start back up once getting warm. i messed with it a lot, could never get it to run right.

so instead of telling him to buy a new engine i put an old briggs flathead on it, it runs better than the OHV crap did brand new!

the OHV motor was sitting in my basement for a long time, i was bored a few days ago so i decided to rip it apart.


ALUMINUM BORE, PLASTIC CAM? not only that, the gaskets are horrible quality, the sheet metal is paper thin, overall the design is the worst engine i have seen



what were they thinking?
 

r97

Measure twice cut once
Messages
3,793
Reaction score
9
Location
Massachusetts, USA
Yup, they have to keep costs down to compete with any of the Chines stuff. Although it seems like a terrible idea, things like an aluminum bore, and plastic cam are perfectly acceptable with the way people look at a lawn mower now. As it is now everything is becoming disposable, if your average Joe can get 3 to 5 summers out of a $200 mower without even changing the oil then they are probably happy to buy another once the one they have decides not to start.

Do I agree with this? No, of course not, I would want to fix it. But if an average guy has had a mower for 5 years and the mechanic wants $125 to fix it.... why not just throw it out and buy a brand spakin' new one for $200!
 

cmbone

New member
Messages
78
Reaction score
2
Location
WA
I Agree!

this is pretty disappointing... never buy a newer B&S engine...

last summer my neighbor had a mower with a (2003) 6.75 OHV briggs on it. the motor would not start back up once getting warm. i messed with it a lot, could never get it to run right.

so instead of telling him to buy a new engine i put an old briggs flathead on it, it runs better than the OHV crap did brand new!

the OHV motor was sitting in my basement for a long time, i was bored a few days ago so i decided to rip it apart.


ALUMINUM BORE, PLASTIC CAM? not only that, the gaskets are horrible quality, the sheet metal is paper thin, overall the design is the worst engine i have seen



what were they thinking?

:iagree: I gotta old flathead briggs & a new intek.
Guess which one is still running?
The Flathead.
 

sideways

Unfinished projects king.
Messages
1,501
Reaction score
2
Location
Perth, Western Australia
Briggs have been sh!t for decades, just about everyone else has always been leagues ahead, both in terms of quality and design.

By far, the worst quality engine I have ever worked on was a 3.5hp Briggs with a late 90's build date. I've worked on tons of Chinese stuff but nothing compares. I'd rather they made the tin work out of plastic (like Honda GCs) than that stupidly thin tin that tears with the first decent yank (and you needed many decent yanks) on the pull starter.....

On another note.

The cams appear to be a self lubricating form of nylon, they're also much lighter than their metal counterparts. Both these factors give better performance.
 

klicky96

New member
Messages
558
Reaction score
1
Location
Sandusky, Ohio
Briggs have been sh!t for decades, just about everyone else has always been leagues ahead, both in terms of quality and design.

By far, the worst quality engine I have ever worked on was a 3.5hp Briggs with a late 90's build date. I've worked on tons of Chinese stuff but nothing compares. I'd rather they made the tin work out of plastic (like Honda GCs) than that stupidly thin tin that tears with the first decent yank (and you needed many decent yanks) on the pull starter.....

On another note.

The cams appear to be a self lubricating form of nylon, they're also much lighter than their metal counterparts. Both these factors give better performance.

Before you start saying Chinese motors are better than Briggs, you should classify yourself. You find an old 1970's Briggs and a brand new Chinese engine, I bet the 70's Briggs outlasts the chinese.
 

Jake.B

New member
Messages
495
Reaction score
0
Location
California-USA
Before you start saying Chinese motors are better than Briggs, you should classify yourself. You find an old 1970's Briggs and a brand new Chinese engine, I bet the 70's Briggs outlasts the chinese.

Exactly, i have a 1961 Briggs and Stratton that a neighbor gave me and it had been sitting outside for 20 years. All i did is replace fluids, clean the carb, clean any rust off of the magneto. It fired right up and ran great. 50 years and it still ran like a champ.
 

sideways

Unfinished projects king.
Messages
1,501
Reaction score
2
Location
Perth, Western Australia
Before you start saying Chinese motors are better than Briggs, you should classify yourself. You find an old 1970's Briggs and a brand new Chinese engine, I bet the 70's Briggs outlasts the chinese.

I have 6 70s and early 80's Briggs, one goes.

I have many Chinese motors, they all go.

That wasn't my point, but seeing as you brought it up I will say that in my experience, Briggs of any age aren't as reliable as other makes of engine.

I live in a farming community and being a guy who knows his way around small engines better than most, I work on a lot of peoples stuff. I would confidently say that I've spend more time fixing peoples old Briggs than I have all other small motors combined, remembering here in Australia Briggs has no where near the market share they do over there, here it's mostly Hondas. A classic example is the pump motors which every farmer has several of. It would seem that Briggs can't sit for very long without needing work to get it going again, also if they aren't used often they tend to crack the sh!ts too. Then you look at a Honda G200 which has been sitting on the edge of dam for 30 years and it's never needed work and starts easily...... Then back at the Briggs which always has a broken pull starter and takes 874756 pulls to start, needs to be filled up with oil every time you start it and needs a carby rebuild every few years.....

From what I've seen of the Honda GX clones (I've rebuilt one (farmer wanted to see if it was lasting well, looked like new inside), and have worked on a few wood chippers and generators with them) they have pretty high quality casting and seem to be put together well, certainly far above Briggs very low current standard and scarily close to Hondas. Clones tin work and linkages tend to be utter crap though, not that that Briggs are much better, especially from about the mid 80s on wards.

Also, we don't know how long Chinese engines will last just yet do we? Just because an engine is made in a country that you consider to make inferior stuff to yours doesn't mean it wont last. Also, standards have moved on tremendously. Old briggs are a really shocking design, even back in the 1970s Honda had roller bearing cranks and engines designed with actual engineering thought as opposed to super basic layouts. A good point here is that way back then Japanese stuff was held in similar regard to Chinese stuff today, I tell you that Honda G series(1970s/80s) engines don't ever die.... GXs are much the same.

I'm sure you think that old cars (as in 1950s and before) are fantastically reliable too? They weren't, major mechanical failures were something that just happened and the service intervals certainly weren't 10'000kms. The engines lasted 2/5s of bugger all too, compared to todays stuff at least.

This is my experience, take from it what you will. Having worked as a small engines mechanic (unqualified) I do have quite a lot of experience with these things.
 

klicky96

New member
Messages
558
Reaction score
1
Location
Sandusky, Ohio
Sorry, but I will never buy another chinese motor. 1.) Carbs get ruined easily, 2.) I burnt the piston rings out running it at not even half throttle, 3.) After I bought new rings, I broke a rod. Now come on, has anyone else broke a rod while not even running the engine full throttle? With my 1967 Briggs, i've never had to replace anything but the oil and spark-plug. I've had it for 3 years after getting it from my grandfather after he bought it brand new. He never replaced anything except the oil and spark-plug. Even the gaskets are still fine.
 

r_chez_08

Should be in the shop...
Messages
4,827
Reaction score
14
Location
Cornwall, UK
I have no problem with chineese gx200 clones. Of course Hondas will outlast them, but you can buy 3/4 chinnese motors for the price (not the right attitude I know!)

I have got an old briggs kool bore which I bought to fix. Do not know the history, however I dislike it. Aluminium bore (nice and scratched) and aluminium bushings (heavily worn). The Honda G motors, especially the G200's are very good.

On a side note, those cam profiles look horrible!
 

jamyers

Well-known member
Messages
1,444
Reaction score
49
Location
Buffalo Gap, TX
...On a side note, those cam profiles look horrible!

I've noted that as well, most of these small engine cam lobes look like their ramp speed is something like 0-to-1Bazillion and back again, no wonder they float like mad over 4K rpm. I haven't profiled one, but I'll bet they're more like an on-off switch that a smooth ramping open and closed.
 

ghostdog

New member
Messages
139
Reaction score
0
As long as harbor freight keeps selling them for around $100 I will unfortunately never be persuaded to go with another motor.
 

Bluethunder3320

New member
Messages
5,677
Reaction score
39
well you get what you pay for. my experiences:

as far as who makes the best small engine.... id have to go with kohler. the only problems i have had with kohler is needle and seat problems in the WALBRO lmk carb. i have fixed a 13 horse with a sheared flywheel key but after that it ran great.

tecumseh carb's are junk. rest of the engine is good. i have had to crack open countless carbs on these.

older flathead briggs i dont have problems with. newer briggs (within last 10 years) are cheap. (already explained this)

honda has been good to me but the airbox on the OHC 5 horse is too restrictive.. simple fix (GCV160)

chinese clones have been very good compared to cost. problems i have had with these are a worn out choke hold, plastic, and a spark plug boot fell apart, and a kill switch broke. these have been pretty tough motors to me.
 

klicky96

New member
Messages
558
Reaction score
1
Location
Sandusky, Ohio
Your right about the newer briggs and tecumsehs. and to agree with you, I love kohler. I completely rebuilt a 10 Horse kohler off of a 1967 John deere 112. They built them things to last.
 

Bluethunder3320

New member
Messages
5,677
Reaction score
39
i got a free 16 horse kohler command. 1994. replaced the carb with an ebay one that was $25 shipped.

runs soooo smooth.


im thinking about getting something like a muniki for my 10hp tecumseh....
 

slideways

New member
Messages
575
Reaction score
6
Its all just parts inside. You guys talk like these things are entire vehicles that are bad or good. A rod/crank/cam/valves and a carb is all it is. As long as they all function its all the same. Just because a Briggs was made in 1970 doesnt make it any better than a clone built in 2012. If you drive it through mud holes and try to rip the starter rope off of it pulling it like a gorilla neither one is going to work. Half of the pics and videos i see on here are of people trying to make sh!t in to a Hershey bar and complaining when it doesn't work. Maintenance is the key, clean your stuff off every time you use it and give it new parts now and then and suddenly that junky clone will run as long as the magical legendary Briggs flatty that everyone is so quick to defend for some reason.
 

kendelrk

redneck engineer
Messages
2,425
Reaction score
9
Location
westland michigan
Slideways have you ever had a flatty briggs over 3hp? Thesse engines were built better and designed better that's why they made a heavy way into racing, yeah its gonna need some parts but guess what, its made better, designed better, and its got some crazy power over a clone. An air filter and exhaust is what 1/2 Hp more, put that on a briggs and it will make some power and a fully adjustable good made carb is a great addition
 

r_chez_08

Should be in the shop...
Messages
4,827
Reaction score
14
Location
Cornwall, UK
R.e. Clones. Internally, they are good IMO.
The bad: basically anything rubber or plastic. Gaskets, spark plug stuff, recoil internals, air filter housings etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top