straight pipe or muffler?

Status
Not open for further replies.

beansdaddy78

JR. Member
Messages
565
Reaction score
2
Location
Carbondale IL.
wow there are a lot of mixed emotions about the subject. i am going to try it both ways and like TOYSTORY did, im going to do 10 passes with each and gonna time them and measure the distance and use my speedometer app (which in my opinion works awesome, and is dead on!) not sure if anybody really cares but ill post in this thread what the outcome is.
 

beansdaddy78

JR. Member
Messages
565
Reaction score
2
Location
Carbondale IL.
another quick question that i just dont think deserves its own thread

is it ok to use an octane boost with premium gas in my briggs 5hp??? and would that help the motor run better at all or worse or could it result in damage?
 

Jcotz

...wasn't there
Messages
374
Reaction score
1
Location
NY
I'm pretty sure the difference is fairly minimal and you won't gain noticeable power from you engine.
 

beansdaddy78

JR. Member
Messages
565
Reaction score
2
Location
Carbondale IL.
ill just make the decision based on how loud it is with the straight pipe compared to the muffler.

thank you everybody for your input
 

exenos

Project Nut
Messages
1,217
Reaction score
0
Location
Ontario, Canada
SOMEONE needs to read up on four stroke engine theory...;)

I'm have read about four stroke exhaust, and I know that the return presure waves created by a tuned pipe are not needed with a four stroke, nor is back pressure needed. I do know that the suction created by a megaphone, or the first half of a tuned pipe are beneficial because it helps to clear the exhaust quicker but is not needed.


Note: Fabroman this is a topic that I know about, unless I was misinformed again :D
 

r_chez_08

Should be in the shop...
Messages
4,827
Reaction score
14
Location
Cornwall, UK
another quick question that i just dont think deserves its own thread

is it ok to use an octane boost with premium gas in my briggs 5hp??? and would that help the motor run better at all or worse or could it result in damage?

Yeah its OK, no it won't help unless you have upped the compression ratio.
 

OzFab

Well-known member
Messages
15,615
Reaction score
76
Location
Warwick Qld, Australia
Note: Fabroman this is a topic that I know about, unless I was misinformed again :D

Hey, I didn't say you were wrong or "misinformed" :roflol: I worded my response very carefully by saying 4 stroke engines need some level of resistance.

I've lost count of the times I've seen cars with blown exhaust maifold gaskets & said "get that fixed or you'll end up with bigger problems". Next time I see the car it's misfiring 'coz it has a burnt valve.

Another example is a conversation I overheard some years ago about a guy who put a 3" straight through exhauston his suzuki swift & wondered why it lost all it's power. Between fits of laughter it was explained to him that this was due to lack of back pressure.

Now, I realise there's a bit of difference between a single piston industrial engine & multi cylinder car engines but, fundamentally, they're the same so, for the most part, the same rules apply.
 

exenos

Project Nut
Messages
1,217
Reaction score
0
Location
Ontario, Canada
Hey, I didn't say you were wrong or "misinformed" :roflol: I worded my response very carefully by saying 4 stroke engines need some level of resistance.

I've lost count of the times I've seen cars with blown exhaust maifold gaskets & said "get that fixed or you'll end up with bigger problems". Next time I see the car it's misfiring 'coz it has a burnt valve.

Another example is a conversation I overheard some years ago about a guy who put a 3" straight through exhauston his suzuki swift & wondered why it lost all it's power. Between fits of laughter it was explained to him that this was due to lack of back pressure.

Now, I realise there's a bit of difference between a single piston industrial engine & multi cylinder car engines but, fundamentally, they're the same so, for the most part, the same rules apply.

I was referring back to our original meeting and the "welding disagreement" and how I had the wrong picture, nothing against what you said now.Although, I would say that a 4 stroke doesn't need back pressure, it just needs something to keep cold air away from the valves to prevent them from cracking.
 

OzFab

Well-known member
Messages
15,615
Reaction score
76
Location
Warwick Qld, Australia
I was referring back to our original meeting and the "welding disagreement" and how I had the wrong picture, nothing against what you said now.Although, I would say that a 4 stroke doesn't need back pressure, it just needs something to keep cold air away from the valves to prevent them from cracking.

Oh, I know that, I was simply enlightening you all to a few experiences I've had

Cracking valves? LOL

I've seen that happen; only once though
 

OzFab

Well-known member
Messages
15,615
Reaction score
76
Location
Warwick Qld, Australia


If you look closely you'll notice a second hairline crack at about the 8 o'clock position.

However, this usually occurs when an engine is run hard when cold, not due to anything even closely related to backpressure
 

Badot

New member
Messages
677
Reaction score
3
Well... in the basic theory of 4 strokes, backpressure is neither required no desirable. But if an engine is designed to use backpressure then it is necessary. If you switch from a muffler to a straight pipe, what do you do? Check the jetting! I have a feeling a bit of backpressure can also cause an effect similar to an egr system (which can potentially stop an exhaust valve from burning... go figure!)

And Fabroman... The valves burning may not be due to the exhaust gaskets leaking, it could be possible that they are both caused by something else rather than one causing the other (ex. engine running too hot could cause both, correct?)

It's the old 'crime rate goes up with ice cream sales' thing.

Although I do fully agree that cold air on a hot valve isn't something you want to experiment with.
 

mike.

Member
Messages
68
Reaction score
1
Location
NE Ohio
This is a specific point but one I have seen a lot about on another forum: Open/straight pipes do have advantages and are "tuneable" in a sense. Race kart guys running Animals and other similar engines adjust the length and diameter of their pipes to effectively move the power band up and down. You sometimes see loop headers on drag mini bikes and race karts for this reason. I cant tell you for sure the exact way to do it but I did make a pipe for my HS50 based on their charts. Its 14 inches long and 3/4" ID to make power at higher RPMs.

I THINK it goes something like this:
Longer pipe = power at high RPM
Shorter = power at low RPM
Larger diameter = power at high RPM
Smaller diameter = power at low RPM
You have to fine tune the length vs the diameter.

I could be completely messing that up...


Also, my engine loves that header so something must be right.
 

beansdaddy78

JR. Member
Messages
565
Reaction score
2
Location
Carbondale IL.
My engine does some backfiring when i let off the gas especially when going fast, should i be concerned about this, i dont remember moving the gears if there is a timing issue but i could have. are there other reasons it may be backfiring? is it unhealthy for the motor? i dont wanna pop the case open again if i can fix it another way so id like to try everything else before opening the motor again. thanks if anybody can help me
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top