I suppose many of us oughta watch how we phrase things. If you think backs aren't gonna go up when you say things like "you guys have got it all figured out" you're not paying much attention to your own phrasing.
We never said the unsprung engine wasn't doable, or even bad. He//, I'm using it on one of my karts to keep things simple. What was said, was that the better option was not as complex as you made it out to be. Then you got touchy. Whatever. Motorhead? Yeah. Nobody "attacked" you.
Now- This forum is an excellent means of asking and answering questions, sharing ideas, and batting theories around. There will be differing opinions, and ultimately an argument is simply the weighing out of opposing opinions. So-
Keep the attitudes in check, and this is not a problem- right?
ANYHOW- As stated, having the engine mounted to the swingarm is the simplest, cheapest way of having rear suspension on a kart, and does it's job decently enough. BUT-
(WARNING-argument here!) For many reasons, it is preferable to have the engine suspended along with the chassis, independant of the rear axle's travel. It usually (but doesn't have to) require a jackshaft which induces additional cost and weight, but many of us use jackshafts for other reasons anyhow, such as the use of a CVT or torque converter. Ultimately, with a small investment in time, money, and thought, you get a lighter, more responsive suspension, and your engine gets a much cushier ride while you bash the he// out of things offroad.
Think we can all make nice, now?
Jeepracer, if you toss up some pics, it'll help us point you in the right direction..