Let's talk Torquey

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bbqjoe

Banned
Messages
3,455
Reaction score
70
Location
Location, Location
I just don't get some of the explanations I'm reading, and I'd sure appreciate a layman's break down.

As I/we understand torque, it is the measurement of force applied by a 1 foot wrench to turn something.
So let's say you have a bolt inserted into a wall, you place a 1 foot wrench on it, and hang a 1lb weight on the end of the wrench, we could then say the bolt is receiving 1 ft lb of torque, correct?

Let's say the bolt is easily turned with that 1lb of pressure.

Let's then say, we are able to place another wrench on that bolt hanging the opposite direction. We hang a 1 lb weight on that one as well.
The bolt doesn't move, because 1 ft pound of torque is being counteracted by an opposite amount of force.

The GX200 supposedly produces appx 9 ft lbs of torque.

This is where I'm tripped up.

I find it hard to believe that a 1 ft wrench with a 9 lb weight hanging in the opposite directing of rotation of the engine would be enough force to stop the engine from rotating. Or would it?

And on top of that, even with some gearing, I just can't imagine how 9 ft lbs can possibly get anything accomplished.

Help me Mr Wizard!
 

Flyinhillbilly

The great cornholio
Messages
2,468
Reaction score
132
Location
North West Arkansas
Here's my take on it right or wrong.

The torque is just a way of measuring rotational force. If you take 9ft/lbs and multiply that by 12 means that you should have 108lbs of rotational force at the crankshaft. Factor in our favorite 6:1 gear ratio and you get 648lbs of rotational force at the hub. The tire of course increases the diameter and changes the final drive ratio, which will affect the rotational force at the contact patch of the tire.

The dyno I'm building starts flexing pretty bad at about 8 ft/lbs and I know for a fact that 8lbs wouldn't budge it, but 8 x 12 = 96lbs of rotational force, which darn sure would move it.
 

Bbqjoe

Banned
Messages
3,455
Reaction score
70
Location
Location, Location
Here's my take on it right or wrong.

The torque is just a way of measuring rotational force. If you take 9ft/lbs and multiply that by 12 means that you should have 108lbs of rotational force at the crankshaft. Factor in our favorite 6:1 gear ratio and you get 648lbs of rotational force at the hub. The tire of course increases the diameter and changes the final drive ratio, which will affect the rotational force at the contact patch of the tire.

The dyno I'm building starts flexing pretty bad at about 8 ft/lbs and I know for a fact that 8lbs wouldn't budge it, but 8 x 12 = 96lbs of rotational force, which darn sure would move it.

Where is this twelve coming from?
 

Flyinhillbilly

The great cornholio
Messages
2,468
Reaction score
132
Location
North West Arkansas
12 inches in a foot. My number may be funded, but it all seems to make sense to me.


Of course I could be wrong, it's happened before, just once, and I don't like to talk about it.
 

Flyinhillbilly

The great cornholio
Messages
2,468
Reaction score
132
Location
North West Arkansas
In a way, but not really. If you look at your average car the lug nut torque spec will be around 80-100 ft/lbs. we all know 500lbs ain't going to hold a wheel on a 5000lb car at 70 around a curve. That lug nut torque is just a representation of the rotational load put on the lug nuts causing much more clamping force. The thread pitch would be the gear ratio.
An engine on a dyno is an odd thing. It has to absorb the power being made in a way that can also measure torque. To stop the engine with a 9lb weight at the end of a 1 ft bar you'd have to be able to produce 9ft/lbs at 0 rpm since it won't let the engine rotate.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    76.1 KB · Views: 4

Whitetrashrocker

Inmate #952016
Messages
5,235
Reaction score
4,732
Location
Southern New Mexico
I just gewlgled " torque explained" and quite a few good explanations came up. Alot of crappy explanations too.

When it comes to specs I want lots of torque.
Exaggerating but I'd take 1hp and 500ftlbs over 500 horse at 1ftlb.
You can get more "work" done that way.
Think of those huge steam tractors. 10- 15 horse maybe? But enough torque to pull a barn.
 

itsid

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,563
Reaction score
261
Location
Ruhrpott [Germany]
Now you're throwing inch pounds around!

when in fact the ONLY real measure (SI) is Newtonmeter :D

but it's the same thing, a standard size FORCE (1 Newton or your arbitrary scale mass under gravitational force)
applied via a standard size lever (one meter.. or an inch, a mm a foot...or half a scroot if you wish)

And yes, you are perfectly correct, you can prevent an engine from running by applying the same amount of torque in the opposite direction,
in case the engine has 12 Nm of torque (roughly 9 ft lbf .. 8.85 to be precise)

BUT make sure to NOT mess up lb with lbf (ponds with poundforce)

it's poundforce you're dealing with in case of torque NOT weight.

One Newton is 0.22480894309971 lbf
and exactly one kg meter/second²

to 'convert' to mass (dead weight) you need to remove the gravitaional force applied (9.81m/s²)
i.e divide by 32,17405 ft/s² in your case so one pound applies 32.2 lbf of force!
one kg 9.81 Newton.

one lbf is roughly 4.45 N btw..
and a foot is roughly 0.3 meters

Back to our 12Nm..
that'd be a four foot lever and a 1kg weight (~2lb) roughly you need to prevent the enigne from rotating.

or 2kg on a 2foot lever, or 4kg on a one foot lever (8.8 lbs)
about'ish (too lazy to accurately convert to non SI units) etc.pp.

and that's the reason we need gear ratios just as Nate said.

you can push much much higher forces with your legs... but not nearly as fast ;)
and the gear ratio converts speed to force and vice versa.

'sid
 

Flyinhillbilly

The great cornholio
Messages
2,468
Reaction score
132
Location
North West Arkansas
Try imagining it like this.
Put a 24 inch crank sprocket on your minibike and you won't budge. Put a 2" crank sprocket on and the torque will go through the roof.
The distance that torque is measured from the centerline of your crank is the effective gear ratio.
 

itsid

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,563
Reaction score
261
Location
Ruhrpott [Germany]
Are you then saying, that it takes 32 pounds of force to make a 1 foot wrench torque to 1 lb.

Sometimes I wish I could drink.

Nope the other way around..

you'd need 32 pounds of weight over 1foot per square second to make ONE lbf

lbf is NOT lb it's lb/s²

don't blame me... I didn't came up wih those ridiculuous units.

I think thet's in fact the unit that just recently crashed a mars lander (since some *one* didn't convert from si to imperial measurements and something broke...)

'sid
 

Bbqjoe

Banned
Messages
3,455
Reaction score
70
Location
Location, Location
Nope the other way around..

you'd need 32 pounds of weight over 1foot per square second to make ONE lbf

lbf is NOT lb it's lb/s²

don't blame me... I didn't came up wih those ridiculuous units.

I think thet's in fact the unit that just recently crashed a mars lander (since some *one* didn't convert from si to imperial measurements and something broke...)

'sid

WUUUUT? Now you're throwing time into the equation!!!:surrender:
 

Rail rider

Inmate # 3192016
Messages
792
Reaction score
6
Location
Planet earth ( the flat one)
I'm heading out to my garage.. 12" pipe wrench in one hand vs a running 8 ft. lb torque motor . Brb I'm going to settle this once and for all. I'll let you know if I stop the shaft or not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top