Independent Rear Suspension

Status
Not open for further replies.

frederic

The Junk Man
Messages
385
Reaction score
1
Location
New Jersey
My son is currently four, and most disappointed he no longer fits comfortably in the electric toy car I made him a couple of years ago. Other than the tires which I purchased 50% at my local Harbor Freight store and the 300W scooter motor, all of the other components were made from junk I had lying around or cut-offs from other projects.

Here is a YouTube video of my son's first drive in March 2008 when he was three. Pretty much engineered on the fly, lots of glue and reworking, and the body leaves a lot to be desired but to be honest I expected him to kiss one of the many big trees we have and destroy it. He proved me wrong ;-)

Youtube Video: Homemade Electric Toy Car

Anyway, we're about to embark on a much larger vehicle, able to seat at least two children his age and a bit older, and of course that introduces lots of variables as far as sizing. My son also "demands" that it looks like Daddy's truck, an F350 crewcab.

I'm starting to collect parts and scrap as I did for the above project but one of the things I will be building into this is an independent rear suspension, preferably with the differential mounted on the chassis and the half-shafts attached with CV's or u-jounts.

I thought I was being clever and when my neighbor's riding mower's rear transaxle died I offered to do the labor in switching out for the new one that he bought, in exchange I could take the old rear for "experimental purposes". All i wanted to do was saw down the housing and see how close to the differential I could get, i.e. narrowing it. This unfortunately didn't work out as planned so I had to abandon that idea for the time being.

So I'm curious if any of you have considered, and possibly sourced inexpensive parts to build an independent rear suspension, and if so, what did you use for a differential?

While I have all the tools to make beveled gears and the necessary carrier, my machining skills are still "entry level" and I would expect to make about 400 sets of useless gears before getting things right enough to be reliable.

This will be directly driven by an electric motor of unknown size, as I have several choices and will select which motor based on my completing the chassis and tossing it on a pair of bathroom scales.

I'm not in a positon to buy an ATV differential for several hundred dollars, but maybe a used one would be a good choice if I could narrow it down?

Any comments, ideas or eyepokes would be welcomed. Thanks.

Frederic
 

mattlepperd

New member
Messages
81
Reaction score
0
I have found and then utilized the carcass of two 4 wheelers in the last couple months. I just put an ad on Craigslist
 

Kaptain Krunch

Pro Junk Collector
Messages
4,636
Reaction score
6
Location
vermont
Just about every rear engine riding mower uses a self contained differential, im sure you could find one for cheap.
 

modelengineer

Lord of the noise
Messages
1,609
Reaction score
2
Location
Sydney, Australia
You don't really need a diff, just use the chain drive to a live axle. Live axle would be MUCH better than a diff for off-road as well.

Just a short axle with CV's/uni's at either end, and a sprocket drive and brake disc in the middle of it. Throw in some bearings and voila.
 

frederic

The Junk Man
Messages
385
Reaction score
1
Location
New Jersey
The first car I made him has a live axle - simple, functional, reliable. Unfortunately when he turns sharp the car shreds the lawn, which displeases my better half. A differential will reduce some of the damage. I attempted to thwart this by making the pin on the one wheel hub "weak" so if he turns to sharp it snaps allowing that wheel to freespin. That works okay but I ended up making a lot of pins last summer ha ha.

I could use a riding mower transaxle as that solves a lot of the problems, but I was unable to narrow the one unit I got to test this idea out.

Maybe the answer is to drive each rear wheel with an electric motor and skip the differential thing altogether.
 

wingnut

New member
Messages
83
Reaction score
0
I assume that you're attempting to shorten the mower transmission so that you can squeeze it between some a-arms for the rear end? Have you considered using trailing arms instead of a-arms and then driving the rear wheels with dual chains? That way, you get lots of suspension travel and the rear wheels can be closer to the width of the transmission.

To be honest though, I like the dual motor idea better. Dual motors will also give you better off road performance since you don't dump all the torque to the wheel with no traction. On the other hand, if you go with a mower transmission, you can power the thing with a cheap lawn mower engine. I've seen old riding mowers as cheap as $100 on craig's list. You can't buy batteries for that much.
 

frederic

The Junk Man
Messages
385
Reaction score
1
Location
New Jersey
Yes, I was trying to narrow a mower transaxle much along the lines of narrowing a rear-end for an all-out drag racer, mount it to the chassis, then use CV's or u-joints to extend out to the spindles which would be hanging off a-arms more than likely. Your idea of using chains and trailing arms is a good one and is quite doable. Thank you for the idea!

I was thinking about a golf cart axle as well because that solves the electric motor drive stuff as well as gives me a complete axle, and narrowing one I imagine to be easy. If I can chop down a Ford 9" I can't imagine a golf cart axle would be any different, just smaller. Though, they're not in the $100 range, even without the motor.

To be honest though, I like the dual motor idea better. Dual motors will also give you better off road performance since you don't dump all the torque to the wheel with no traction. On the other hand, if you go with a mower transmission, you can power the thing with a cheap lawn mower engine. I've seen old riding mowers as cheap as $100 on craig's list. You can't buy batteries for that much.

That is also true... but no matter what the mechanicals end up looking like it's going to be electric anyway, because it's fume-free and I can build a controller for a motor much easier than I believe my 4 y/o son can control a throttle and a brake. If he were ten years old I could go either way.

Doesn't mean I have to stay away from gas, but that's my preference if possible. Thanks again for the tips and advice, I'll keep hunting for a nearly-free mower. I picked up a John Deere (and trailer!) that was in fact completely free off Craigs List two weeks ago, but the ad misrepresented the mower completely indicating the engine and deck was toast. Turned out the plug was fouled and the deck wasn't attached to the mounts right, so it was binding on the rear tire. A couple of cotter pins later and one shiney new spark plug and it was too nice to cut up and I use it to mow my lawn and haul debris from out back to the curb.

So, back to looking for riding mowers again ;-) Thanks!
 

frederic

The Junk Man
Messages
385
Reaction score
1
Location
New Jersey
Okay, I'm back to insane thinking.

Four wheels, four spindles, upper/lower a-arms. Independent all around. Doable.

Mount one electric motor on each spindle, driving the wheel directly (or) through a chain with a small sprocket on the motor and a larger sprocket on the axle. Axle supported by a pair of double roller bearings, one per side of the axle.

This eliminates half-shafts, differentials, mounts, hosings, CV joints, and the need for highly expensive big motors. Four 500W motors approximately equals one 2000W motor, I would think, not taking motor efficiency into consideration.

Found an eBay a $70 motor (4" diameter, 4" long) that produces 1200W peak, and in my calculations is likely to produce a 800-825W continuous power rating.

Spindle would start out as a 4" square aluminum block, 8" long machined to desired shape.

Shaft is 3/4" diameter with a woodruff keyslot suitable for the mower rims I have (with 18x9.50-8 tires)

Small sprocket on motor is 11 tooth for #25 chain.

Large spricket on spindle is 55 tooth (6-3/8" diameter, I think)

There would be enough "meat" on the top and bottom of spindle to drill, tap and thread 3/4" diameter holes for bolting on the rod-ends that would be part of the upper and lower a-arms.

The rear spindles would be identical to the front spindles, except the tie-rods would be fixed to the chassis at the appropriate point so as the suspension articulates camber does not change.

Crude drawing to illustrate the idea.

Green = machined live axle stub and larger sprocket.
Red = double roller bearings.
Blue = electric motor plus smaller sprocket.
White = Spindle plus motor mount.

The reason the spindle would be beveled in the front is to provide some clearance for the 8" rims, even though the rims have an extension shaft on the inside of the rim. If this is necessary, I would actually turn the spindle on the lathe and make it more of a cone than a simple straight-cut milling operation at 45 degrees.

I haven't done any math to determine appropriate motor size nor appropriate gearing, and instead this is just my imagination going a little wild.

I must drown the voices... with beer. ;-)
 

Attachments

  • toytruck.jpg
    toytruck.jpg
    32.6 KB · Views: 8

frederic

The Junk Man
Messages
385
Reaction score
1
Location
New Jersey
Not to poke anyone for a response... but what do you think about the idea of mounting a small scooter motor on each wheel in this fashion?

Would a 12 tooth gear driving a 55 tooth gear on each spindle be enough to have the thing accelerate?
 

ddlyspdr

New member
Messages
28
Reaction score
0
it should be enough to move it, what wattage, hp electric motors u plan on using??
 

frederic

The Junk Man
Messages
385
Reaction score
1
Location
New Jersey
The electric motors are "rated" by the ebay seller as 1200W, 1.5HP, 48V 29A scooter motors.

They are 4" diameter with three ears, and 4" deep.

I don't buy that rating, but was thinking if it was exhaggerated by 50%, that would give me four 500W motors with a 12-tooth sprocket driving a 18" tire driven by a 55 tooth sprocket.

Think if I apply current to the four motors it will move?
 

frederic

The Junk Man
Messages
385
Reaction score
1
Location
New Jersey
I have two threads going that are "sort of" related, but at this time it looks very likely I'll be taking possession of a 3-wheeled cushman cart with a rusty metal dump bed for a few bucks.

The seller assures me it will fit into the back of my pickup with the tailgate closed and I can unbolt the dump bed if it doesn't, as it overhangs a good 8-10 inches based on what I see in the pictures.

So, the rear axle problem for my son's truck kart has been solved, assuming I win the bid (the seller seems to think I will).

While this is not an electric cart it does have a huge pulley on the rear axle so I can take the pulley off the transmission and fabricate a mount to the electric motor I will be getting at some point, and from there I have the basic parts.

To the moderator of this fine forum - once I start posting my build log, would you prefer I do it in "projects" or in "electric carts". Just want to follow the rules.

Thanks!
 

mattlepperd

New member
Messages
81
Reaction score
0
What you are building sounds an awful lot like what I just built.
I spent the 8 million dollars in research so you dont have to.
This thing works great,has plenty of power and battery life.
It hauls two adults like nothing and is as fast (or slow) as you want to gear it.I used a bunch of scrap yard stuff,some roll cage tubing for the frame and a motor and controller from carl at EDRIVES. Let me kniow if you want more info.
BTW,I put the second set of bearings on the rear axle because the motor has so much torque that nearly ripped apart my Northern Tool differential.
 

Attachments

  • 001.jpg
    001.jpg
    127.2 KB · Views: 29
  • 002.jpg
    002.jpg
    97.9 KB · Views: 18
  • 003.jpg
    003.jpg
    124.8 KB · Views: 22

frederic

The Junk Man
Messages
385
Reaction score
1
Location
New Jersey
Does edrives/carl? I'd appreciate the info when you get a chance. Thank you for the pictures, they're really helpful. The Northern Tool diff looks larger than I imagined, which is good news.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top