Honda G200 - EFI Conversion

Status
Not open for further replies.

Poboy kartman

Senior Moments Member
Messages
12,461
Reaction score
73
Location
White Settlement Texas
Tell us more Josip....ending forever? ....or just the summer?

What are you studying and what level are you at? Apparently, wherever you are studying is working....and....I'll put money on you being "above average "!
 

NewbCarter

Member
Messages
403
Reaction score
4
Location
Solin , Croatia
Tell us more Josip....ending forever? ....or just the summer?

What are you studying and what level are you at? Apparently, wherever you are studying is working....and....I'll put money on you being "above average "!

Well , still in middle school , tho studying Mehatronics , basically robotics , programming ( CNC machines included ) , pneumatics and hydraulics , etc
And yes , till the summer , then the last grade and then college ... by then i need to decide for hardware or software pretty much

Sad truth is , the school being the only one of its type in the region doesnt have all of the "required" tools / machinery ..

I mean , the lathes we worked on are from 1945ish , the PCs are all still running either XP or older ...
 

Poboy kartman

Senior Moments Member
Messages
12,461
Reaction score
73
Location
White Settlement Texas
See...that's the thing....when I graduated HS here in America....(a mere 40+ years ago....) there wasn't much emphasis on real world skills, nor any attempt at directing young people in career directions.....(or even MENTIONING career opportunities or options...)

I have an idea that things haven't gotten much better in the public school system...and doubt that the kind of stuff you are studying is available even in High School. Then we wonder why America is falling behind?

Perhaps...if we took a little time to look in the mirror, instead of thinking it's our duty to drag the third world into the 20th Century...we could become great again. However, we are sliding into 3rd world status....( on terms of a competent....tech ready , trained workforce...) and it IS the status quo traditional schooling! )

Just as in my day....the traditional American schooling will give all the necessary basic skills, but no direction or specialized instructions for a career ....

(Something a outside tech school can do in mere months....) Frankly, I don't get it!!!!

Had someone gave me some insight on careers....I might be a brain surgeon now

..instead of a carpenter! (Seriously, THAT is my own fault, though, I just couldn't see the hours or time required to become a doctor...as something my wild and crazy guy youth could do.....)

However, I DO feel a bit ripped off on the athletic thing....back then....being a Pro didn't pay much ....if I'd had known I could have made millions just playing ball and pushing shoes....I'd have done it!
 

Toycrusher

New member
Messages
168
Reaction score
0
Location
Deep Deep South Texas
Building and programming a functional EFI system is quite an undertaking for a middle school project. I applaud you. I suggest you study up on mechanical injection theory of operation. Going to be much easier to duplicate that strategy than a typical automotive EFI system
 

NewbCarter

Member
Messages
403
Reaction score
4
Location
Solin , Croatia
Well , the sensors have finally arrived ! I will have them with me later today , and il probably get them mounted on the engine on saturday ...

In the meantime i managed to find some time to sit down and calculate on how much fuel does this perticular engine need .

So we know its 197cc in displacement , with the governor removed , probably good for 5k RPM ( it probably does go higher but for the sake of calculation and safety , il round it up to 5000 RPM ) .

N/A engines such as this one have a volumetric efficency of 80% to 90% .
From the engines manual , the fuel consumption is 394g/KWh . (3600 RPM , 3,7kW )

Going by how 4strokes operate ...

Air consumed by the engine @5000 RPM , volumetric efficency of 85% , 197cc displacement and lets say the engine is at sea level , so manifold pressure is equivalent to the air density at sea level.

2500cycles * 85% * 0.000197 cubic meters * 1.225 kg / cubic meters = 0.512815625 kg/min

Now the engine at full tilt ( no load , assuming 85% volum. efficency ) consumes about half a kilogram of air per hour .

Fuel used in this situation is 1/15 of the air used , we get 0.03418770833 kg/min of fuel being used .

Gasoline density being 719.7kg/m3 , it ends up being 0.047 L/min , or 2.82L/Hour... IF my math is correct ...

If anyone can shine some knowledge on this , please do so :wai:
 

itsid

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,563
Reaction score
261
Location
Ruhrpott [Germany]
well sounds good at first... then again...
remember those old fiat cinquecentos (the real ones, not the retro crap)?
Those engines are commonly 500cc ('ish.. but for the sake of argument let's stick with 500)
so two and a half times the combustion volume of your engine..
(there even was a 600cc version with three times that volume)
All those had an electric fuel pump that was capable of delivering no more than 5 l/hr
and those engines also ran at a max of roundabout 5k rpm when beaten with a stick...

So from that info it's hard to believe that you'll need close to 3 l/hr for 200ccs

I haven't done the math yet, but that just doesn't feel right ;)
from the guts I'd say 2.3l/hr maybe 2.5... not more

'sid
 

Poboy kartman

Senior Moments Member
Messages
12,461
Reaction score
73
Location
White Settlement Texas
Needs more decimal places.

well sounds good at first... then again...
remember those old fiat cinquecentos (the real ones, not the retro crap)?
Those engines are commonly 500cc ('ish.. but for the sake of argument let's stick with 500)
so two and a half times the combustion volume of your engine..
(there even was a 600cc version with three times that volume)
All those had an electric fuel pump that was capable of delivering no more than 5 l/hr
and those engines also ran at a max of roundabout 5k rpm when beaten with a stick...

So from that info it's hard to believe that you'll need close to 3 l/hr for 200ccs

I haven't done the math yet, but that just doesn't feel right ;)
from the guts I'd say 2.3l/hr maybe 2.5... not more

'sid

Ask and you shall receive....:lolgoku:
 

NewbCarter

Member
Messages
403
Reaction score
4
Location
Solin , Croatia
well sounds good at first... then again...
remember those old fiat cinquecentos (the real ones, not the retro crap)?
Those engines are commonly 500cc ('ish.. but for the sake of argument let's stick with 500)
so two and a half times the combustion volume of your engine..
(there even was a 600cc version with three times that volume)
All those had an electric fuel pump that was capable of delivering no more than 5 l/hr
and those engines also ran at a max of roundabout 5k rpm when beaten with a stick...

So from that info it's hard to believe that you'll need close to 3 l/hr for 200ccs

I haven't done the math yet, but that just doesn't feel right ;)
from the guts I'd say 2.3l/hr maybe 2.5... not more

'sid

I dont know , since im not an expert in this field at all .. this is all i found over the net , used the formulas at hand and common sence ..

But then again , the engine is ported as of now ... and my math is probably off ...

What i do find interesting is this : http://www.ecotrons.com/products/small_engine_fuel_injection_kit/

On their kit , it says : 3 BAR fuel pressure regulator and a 25L/h pump ! 25 !

And the fuel injectors are anywhere from 38 to 248 grams / hour .
 

itsid

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,563
Reaction score
261
Location
Ruhrpott [Germany]
Ask and you shall receive....:lolgoku:
what? I haven't included any alienating math at all ....

Oh btw I was browsing through some more "hints"
taken from a Honda GX200 [QX] brochure..

that engine under load slurps 1.7 l/hr of 85oct fuel at it's govened max speed...
[all stock of course]

1.7 times 5 divided by 3.6 and we end up with 2.361 l/hr for 5000 rpms.
Man I was close, wasn't I :D

But G200 it is... so I read 390 g/kWh or 290 g/HPh @ 3600
so 1443 - 1450 g/hr under load @ 3600 rpms
again divide by 3.6 and multiply by 5 to accomodate for the increased rpms...
that's 2004 - 2014 g/hr

considering the fuel density of 719.7kg/m3 (just say 720 kg/m³... oh btw that's @ 15°C so it'll be less at common kart driving temperature ;))
anywhoo considering 720 kg/m³
(conveniently 720 g/l ---- ahhh metric values soooo nice to work with :D)

that's 2.78 - 2.79 l/hr

uups.. you've been correct.. nearly 3l/hr of fuel! wouldn't have thought it'd be that high to be honest.

Oh Normed fuel can be as heavy as 775 g/l (according to DIN EN 228 again at 15°C)
that'd be 2.58 - 2.59 l/hr
and I'm just about close with my assumption again :D

Anyways, an EFI will likely change the fuel consumption anyways, just as rejetting would..
you might get away with a leaner mix, or you might need to richen up the ratio.
depending on timing precision and diffusion and all those nasty little things;
only your plug can tell in the end.

So yeah, dialing in towards 3l/hr isn't a bad idea; you can always tweak your code and lean it down again;
a small trimpot can do that in the testing phase for convenience ;)

'sid
 

NewbCarter

Member
Messages
403
Reaction score
4
Location
Solin , Croatia
what? I haven't included any alienating math at all ....

Oh btw I was browsing through some more "hints"
taken from a Honda GX200 [QX] brochure..

that engine under load slurps 1.7 l/hr of 85oct fuel at it's govened max speed...
[all stock of course]

1.7 times 5 divided by 3.6 and we end up with 2.361 l/hr for 5000 rpms.
Man I was close, wasn't I :D

But G200 it is... so I read 390 g/kWh or 290 g/HPh @ 3600
so 1443 - 1450 g/hr under load @ 3600 rpms
again divide by 3.6 and multiply by 5 to accomodate for the increased rpms...
that's 2004 - 2014 g/hr

considering the fuel density of 719.7kg/m3 (just say 720 kg/m³... oh btw that's @ 15°C so it'll be less at common kart driving temperature ;))
anywhoo considering 720 kg/m³
(conveniently 720 g/l ---- ahhh metric values soooo nice to work with :D)

that's 2.78 - 2.79 l/hr

uups.. you've been correct.. nearly 3l/hr of fuel! wouldn't have thought it'd be that high to be honest.

Oh Normed fuel can be as heavy as 775 g/l (according to DIN EN 228 again at 15°C)
that'd be 2.58 - 2.59 l/hr
and I'm just about close with my assumption again :D

Anyways, an EFI will likely change the fuel consumption anyways, just as rejetting would..
you might get away with a leaner mix, or you might need to richen up the ratio.
depending on timing precision and diffusion and all those nasty little things;
only your plug can tell in the end.

So yeah, dialing in towards 3l/hr isn't a bad idea; you can always tweak your code and lean it down again;
a small trimpot can do that in the testing phase for convenience ;)

'sid

So now what i have to figure out if the injector i have planned will work ...

And for the code , i was thinking about it a bit ...
For would be best suited as this is a highly repetitive task , and do it so that i have a set parameter that is the AF ratio and have 2 input parameters , those being the throttle position and RPM .

The fourth parameter is the amount of fuel which i need to figure out with the injector ... size ? fuel pump ?
 

itsid

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,563
Reaction score
261
Location
Ruhrpott [Germany]
Okay, I never tried to pull a stunt like making my own EFI, so I know about nothing about that.

that being said:
the fuel pump just needs to be powerful enough to provide the pressure needed, which is likely every EFI fuel pump you can find. soooo I wouldn't worry about it too much, get one from a junk yard, hook it up to 12V and be done with it for now...
A smaller (say motorcycle) fuelpump later on will still have you covered.
they all provide 25l/hr or more because they need to provide the pressure and those two values go hand in hand more often than not ;)

A fuel injector... well there are a handfull of options actually..
personally I'd grab just any that is meant for a similar combustion chamber (say an 800cc-900cc fuel injected four cylinder motorcycle)
But frankly, my best guess is... a bigger one will also work just as nicely, you only need to adjust the spray timing down a hair...
and that's where the mentioned trimpot comes in handy;
add an additional read out for the trimpot and adjust timing according to it's resistance.
maybe a second to adjust the 'start' of the injection slightly.

that way you don't need to hook up a laptop everytime you want to tweak a value;
when you're happy with the result, you can read the trimpot over serial and fix the setting to the code (remove the now obsolete lines of code and you're good)

once you're done tweaking all the possible options (maybe even created a lookup table for fuzzy settings like humidity or air temp etc.)
you can always upload the code to a different package .. for testing the arduino should be fine ;)

'sid
 

chancer

ɔ ɥ ɐ u ɔ ǝ ɹ
Messages
9,358
Reaction score
97
Location
COMFORT, TEXAS
Nice Job NEWB! It is not often that when someone throws math around You get a response from Sid Like "uups you were right, i wouldn't have thought that."

Keep up the good math!
 

NewbCarter

Member
Messages
403
Reaction score
4
Location
Solin , Croatia
Nice Job NEWB! It is not often that when someone throws math around You get a response from Sid Like "uups you were right, i wouldn't have thought that."

Keep up the good math!

Miracles do happen ! :funnypost:

http://www.njuskalo.hr/moto-dijelovi-ostali/gilera-nexus-500-injektor-dizna-oglas-15307761
That is the injector i planned to use
http://www.njuskalo.hr/moto-agregati/gilera-nexus-500-klapna-gasa-oglas-15307778
Throttle body
http://www.njuskalo.hr/moto-dijelovi-ostali/gilera-nexus-pumpa-goriva-rezervarom-oglas-14136358
Pump and reservoar combo

I thought that the injector from a 500cc would be too much but as u said PWM can help with that.

Cherry on top would be a form of forced induction ..:wai:
http://m.ebay.com/itm/201575655786
 

NewbCarter

Member
Messages
403
Reaction score
4
Location
Solin , Croatia
injector is a tiny bit expensive IMHO..
Honda CBR injectors can be had vor 20 € the one of a 2.0 Ford Probe for less than ten.
So 47 for a Gilera is a bit high plus 33 for the throttle body...
Offer him 50 for the two together (meet at 60)
or get this one:
http://www.ebay.de/itm/GILERA-NEXUS-500-THROTTLE-BODIES-INJECTORS-/400932672249

'sid

PS the Nexus 250 also comes with EFI... ;)

Yea expanding the search to small car engines aswell..

Would be best to get the complete thing .. less $ and i know it works together

EDIT :
Injectors : http://www.njuskalo.hr/motor-pogonski-dijelovi/toyota-aigo-1.0-2008-oglas-16123072
Throttle Body : http://www.njuskalo.hr/motor-pogons...klopka-gasa-hyundai-accent-1.3-oglas-14734115
Pump : http://www.njuskalo.hr/ostali-autodijelovi/pumpa-goriva-vectra-oglas-12570028
Battery : http://www.njuskalo.hr/ostala-autoo...2v-5ah-ribici-kamperi-izletnici-oglas-3412252

In total 395 kunas or around 52 euros .... should suffice . Only potential issue is the throttle body , and how to adapt it to the intake ... but il figure something out ...
 

NewbCarter

Member
Messages
403
Reaction score
4
Location
Solin , Croatia
And i was thinking about ignition , which i thought of assembling myself , but i do have a CDI unit from an old generator set ... hoping its DC powered ..
 

NewbCarter

Member
Messages
403
Reaction score
4
Location
Solin , Croatia
Maybe you want to read some of this:
http://www.nanoefi.com/
an opensource open hardware atmega328p based EFI

maybe you get some ideas, maybe grab a line of code or learn a few tricks...
who knows ;)

'sid

Definetly looks interesting Sid ! Ty for the link and idea aswell .

Tho , i have a question : IF the CDI i have turns out to be a DC one , i still need a magneto / coil assembly in order to have a usable spark ?

In the meantime , il use PCB Artist , to produce a prototype PCB on which everything will be mounted . Including the power delivery circuitry ( the magnet sensors need 12V and the tachometer aswell but the ATMega328P needs 5V , and so do the thermocouples and pressure transducers .. )
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top