i think what's confusing for the new guys is when the old guys argue like this. a TC is flat out the best option for MOST of the people registered on this site. yes, i realize that certain types of karts aren't designed for or allowed to have a TC, but for the average guy with his 5-13hp kart - a TC will always be the better choice for performance and durabilty. so we might as well steer the new guys in the right direction right from the beginning, so they can focus on learning other important stuff that is hard enough to figure out without wondering why their clutch is burning up and they have no balls.
A TC might be the best option for MOST of the people on the site, but it is not the MOST practical option.
You speak about most of the members on the site. Most of the members here do not have 13 HP engines. Most of them have 5-6.5 HP engines. Most of the members on here are also still school going age, so they do not have cash to buy an expensive TC. When you do have an engine of 13HP, you are going to be sinking $400 into a comet 40 series. Not too many people on this site can do that. The whole aim of this site is DIY, which essentially means people are trying to save money.
Yes, in a perfect world where we could all buy what we want, I would suggest a TC for EVERY kart. It is just not practical though. That is why the humble centrifugal clutch is actually the BEST clutch for most people. If we have to spend a little time helping them with gearing...thats fine. Just keep in mind that you also have to know how to gear your TC just as much as you need to know for your cent clutch. You can burn your cent clutch, as well as burn belts on your TC with incorrect gearing.
The OP has a TC already, that is why I have said that if he can use it, for THIS application it is probably the best