well two possibilities actually:
1) you ordered the incorrect belt
maybe by chance someone found a std v belt with a part number that was similar enough to one of a TC belt for you to order the wrong size belt.
such difference in width ('extreme') is likely pointing in that direction.
2) your order of operation is flawed.
remove just the outer part of the driver clutch (moveable sheave, engine side) slip the belt on the driven, put it around the centershaft of the driver, reinstall moveable sheave of the driver and be done.
what partnumber did you order?
what maxtorque TC do you have (standalone or Kitform with backplate and fixed CtC distance?)
and as mckutzy said:
to make things much easier... POST PICS!
'sid