Flywheel explosion evidence

Status
Not open for further replies.

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
Thanks Russ, I appreciate that.
If I'm wrong, tell me I'm wrong, and why. If I'm behaving like an immature idiot, so be it. But that stuff was totally uncalled for.
If my last post doesn't put the BS to rest, I'll leave it alone. I've got better things to do that online peeing contests.
EDIT- Robbie, you're absolutely right. Precisely why I didn't sign up to "the unnamed lawnmower racing" forum. ;)
 

devino246

Official DIYGK Chem Nerd
Messages
3,856
Reaction score
17
Location
Lynchburg, VA
At least we've gotten some attention to this thread. If we get a ton of posts, the mythbusters are more inclined to test it.
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
I hope so. Surely it's a more pressing issue then "does a lighter blow up when you throw it against a wall?", or "Does eating watermelon and baking soda really kill you?".
 

Russ2251

AZUSA:Powered by LAWN-BOY
Messages
6,622
Reaction score
47
Location
Huntington Station, Long Island, NY
Surely it's a more pressing issue then "does a lighter blow up when you throw it against a wall?", or "Does eating watermelon and baking soda really kill you?".
Of coarse!!!...and who really cares about that stuff. Probably just meant to take up air time.
I've been scouring the web for documentation of flywheel explosions for a couple of years now. I have seen nothing even closely related to anything we deal with. Even in racing applications it is an exceedingly rare occurrence.
 

anderkart

Moderator
Messages
6,432
Reaction score
392
Location
Surprise Arizona USA
You guys probably aren't going to find anyone that's built and raced industrial engines for years on that forum. If you want some worthy adversaries to debate the flywheel myth I think you should get a thread going over on this forum: http://karting.4cycle.com/forumdisplay.php?f=120


I doubt you'd ever get Myth busters interested, but Arc (a company that manufactures/sells billet racing flywheels) already had some tests ran on a stock Yellow 6.5 clone flywheel where at 11,250rpm it finally threw a magnet but never did blow up. Info here: http://karting.4cycle.com/showthread.php?t=203981&highlight=flywheel+failure

On the other hand here's a thread/pics of a clone flywheel that supposedly blew up at 6100rpm: http://karting.4cycle.com/showthread.php?t=310349&highlight=exploding+flywheel

All I know is the stock flywheel in my Star engine has proven over the years to be safe up to at least 6500rpm, but then again its not a clone flywheel that was mass produced by an outside vendor with the lowest bid...
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
I have an idea, that may or may not be worth the effort. It does not fully address the issues, but might serve useful.

I have an older Tec H60 with a bad coil that I have no use for. It is completely stock except for an electronic ignition conversion done a few years ago. I propose to bolt it to a platform and drive the crankshaft with a 120v AC motor. I would remove the spark plug so that the motor doesn't have to overcome the engine's compression. The motor turns at 1750RPM. I would use a combination of sprockets or pulleys to drive the crankshaft to 5000+RPM. I could achieve 5250 RPM on the crank with a .33 overdrive ratio. Out in the open and from a safe distance, I could start the motor with a long extension cord, and see what happens.

I realize this would not address certain factors, but would spin-test a factory flywheel above 5000RPM.

EDIT- I could also remove the governor gear and flyweights so that their failure would not cause larger failure.

Your thoughts?
 

Russ2251

AZUSA:Powered by LAWN-BOY
Messages
6,622
Reaction score
47
Location
Huntington Station, Long Island, NY
If you could you get it spin over 10k... I would truly be impressed.
I think 10k would be the minimum to drive the point home.
If I had the means to pull this off, I would remove all internals... camshaft, rod, etc..
Reason being that something will give up (rod) long before flywheel does.
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
Interesting. I could remove the camshaft to keep the valvetrain from being a concern. But if I remove the piston and rod, would I not create a horrible balance situation?
If the shaft wasn't tapered, I'd just mount the flywheel to a bearing-supported shaft, but I do not have access to a machine shop.
 

Russ2251

AZUSA:Powered by LAWN-BOY
Messages
6,622
Reaction score
47
Location
Huntington Station, Long Island, NY
But if I remove the piston and rod, would I not create a horrible balance situation?
You are correct and would throw off the test.
I'm sure small engine manufacturers have a way of testing their flywheels in a stand alone situation. Probably similar to tire balancing equipment.
NASA could do it in a heartbeat. HEY...let's contact them!!! I have several FW's I could donate. All of different manufacture, sizes and age.
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
So in your opinion, should I bother? Would we learn anything? I could conduct a poll, but I'm concerned about the results. I'm not out to destroy a more or less perfectly good engine for laffs, I want to contribute to the cause.
 

robbie

New member
Messages
857
Reaction score
9
Location
Osceola, Missouri
The experiment has already been done many times, without anybody paying attention. I did the math and figured out that my mini bike engine was going at least 5600 rpm, and it didn't blow up. I'm sure that lots of others have gone faster. If flywheel explosions were a serious concern, you probably would have heard about it more than once or twice.

Sometimes there are manufacturing defects which will never cause a problem at 3600 RPM, and there are guys who run their engines beyond specs but usually don't get a defective flywheel. I think the explanation of the myth is that once in a while the planets all line up and a defective casting ends up on a kart spinning at 7500 RPM. It may happen sometimes, but you're not likely to see it happen.

I read the thread at the mythbusters forum again, and I think only one good, on-topic point was made (besides the original idea for an experiment), and unfortunately I have to say that the SR racing guy made it. Cast metal has some variance, so the test wouldn't prove much. Years of karting experience has already proven as much as you need to know, which is that you're not likely to get a flywheel with a defective spot, and you're not likely to see one blow up.
 

Russ2251

AZUSA:Powered by LAWN-BOY
Messages
6,622
Reaction score
47
Location
Huntington Station, Long Island, NY
So in your opinion, should I bother? Would we learn anything?
Might learn something, but 5300+ rpm really won't prove or disprove anything (in my opinion).
I consistently run my power plants at over 6k with no issues. Not even reed valve flutter. I have no doubt that I can go higher still. The qustion is...do I really want to.
I would like to know at what point they (flywheels) WILL fly apart.
I do not wish to approach this limit, but would like to see it done. A frame by frame analysis would be great.
Every once in a while, this flywheel question comes up and is never fully addressed.
In truth, I have blown 2 flywheels for reasons that had nothing to do with high rpm.
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
Well, it was a thought. I do not have the the technology to do a highspeed film, or frame-by-frame analysis. I probably could spin the wheel to 10k with higher gearing.

Robbie- yes SR did make a good point, something I already suspected to be true- Nevertheless, it was refreshing to read such a post without attitude.

EDIT- Robbie, where are these experiments documented? After all, isn't that the point of all of this? I am sure Russ would agree...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top