Eletronic clutches. Idea.

Status
Not open for further replies.

B.M.800

TheBeal.
Messages
2,387
Reaction score
26
Location
Central PA
So lets say we got a regular clutch on our engine, then we have that clutch hooked to a JS with a couple E clutches on it.

Could we then have a few switches hooked up to the e clutches, so then you could disengage one, and engage the other... effectively changing gears?

That is my question, would it be efficient? Would it work well with more than 2? Would a high(30-40mph) kart or low(20-25mph) be better? Would there be too much strain on the engine from engaging the clutches at different speeds, or hard on the clutches? Or would it be eating up batteries? Or eat up clutches?


:idea2:
 

B.M.800

TheBeal.
Messages
2,387
Reaction score
26
Location
Central PA
I dont think you quit got the idea... or maybe you do, and I dont get the idea? :D

Regaurdless, here is a fancy MS Paint of what I mean...


The clutch on the engine is not a E clutch, jus a regular, lets say Hillard. The dark red are the E clutches. You would start with the low gear one engaged, then to uppen the gearing, let off the gas, switch to the higher gearing. I know I put 2 switches in there, but I guess one would be fine.
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
MIGHT work, might not. Obviously, you've found a way around the fact that electromagnetic clutches engage very harshly. That's the big one. However, whether they would actually tolerate that sorta duty remains to be seen. If you can build this cheaply, I say go for it!
 

r97

Measure twice cut once
Messages
3,793
Reaction score
9
Location
Massachusetts, USA
Looks like a feasible idea, if your up to making it I would be interested to see show it works out! I have been pondering all kinds of 2 speed setups for quite some time. You will need too make/acquire a wire detangler, or do the clutches have one built in? One improvement I will add is that you should replace the low range clutch with a one-way needle bearing. You should also look for an engine with a powerful charging system (maybe you could add your own?).
 

HellSpawn

New member
Messages
476
Reaction score
2
Location
Wadena, Minnesota
This would be a very interesting setup. heck, if you were good with electronics you could make a paddle/pushbutton shift too. I'm interested in seeing how one would mount the clutches and keep the stationary side..well stationary. And also attach sprockets instead of a pulley. (I don't think I've ever seen a EM clutch use chain.)
 

B.M.800

TheBeal.
Messages
2,387
Reaction score
26
Location
Central PA
Yeah, If I can find some E clutches for cheap at a flea market or something, I will definatly try to make something. I remember seeing some at a small machinery show, maybe the guy will be back and still have em... dont remember the price.

Maybe I could make some simple e clutches, and make a small scale rig... or the off chance one could be built that would handle the strain... think something could be made usin a drill press, lathe, various cutters and dremmel? My brother does work at a specialty machine shop, so maybe he could help me out some.

I wonder maybe instead of a regular clutch on the engine, a TC might be better(?). If done correctly(assuming it would work) a kart could be built to go a good 60mph and still climb a good sized hill...

Muwahaha... So I have this pannel thing that says 4 speed stick shift...lol
 

fowler

New member
Messages
5,463
Reaction score
18
Location
Bullsbrook West Aus
shifting up would work really easy
but shifting down
u really need a clutch that alows over run
otherwize u will wear clutch out as the gear change forces the engine revs up
or worse just lock the back wheels up and slide
 

B.M.800

TheBeal.
Messages
2,387
Reaction score
26
Location
Central PA
Not sure I understand what you mean...

To downshift, you would let up on the gas then you would slow down and then you would flip the switch to turn off the high gear e clutch. Once that one is off, there would be no connection from the engine to axle. As the engine revs down, the clutch on it wouldnt grip as much, so then flip the switch to the low gear and gas it up.

Are you meaning wear on the clutch on the engine? Or the E clutches?
 

fowler

New member
Messages
5,463
Reaction score
18
Location
Bullsbrook West Aus
as in
when u down shift

unless u get the revs close to ground speed when u let the clutch out itwill force the engine to meet the wheel speed putting alot of stain on the drive train

or u will go to idle and change gears then as u built the revs up the clutch will eather grab and do the same as above or the clutch will do alot of slipping

the idea would work but u would have to take alot of care when changing gear
 

crazyman

New member
Messages
239
Reaction score
1
Location
Yorkville Il
It would work splendidly if you built it then learned the science of driving it. Sorta like shifting a car without the clutch, but without as much delay/work..... A slide switch with two or three sets of contacts, as many contacts as clutches..

If a mower PTO clutch can withstand cutting three foot tall grass, it can surely handle a shift with no load. I bet that it would shift under power semi-reliably even. No load shifts for a lifetime to pay for the clutches at $120 a piece...

As to the above poster, Fowler, "unless u get the revs close to ground speed when u let the clutch out it will force the engine to meet the wheel speed putting alot of strain on the drive train", imagine a mower with 3 heavy stationary blades singing along at 3600 rpm and engaging the PTO and vvvvrrmmmmmm in a half second... Magnetism is strong, and engines sound cool when forced to downshift.. All the revs and lean pops out the exhaust... It would drag the RPMs down quick enough..
 

HellSpawn

New member
Messages
476
Reaction score
2
Location
Wadena, Minnesota
Considering centrifugal clutches cannot engage backwards (the drivetrain would just spin the outer clutch bell) downshifting would be fine aslong as you let off the gas and let the shoes disengage.

This idea is actually very plausible if you can change the pulleys out for sprockets of different tooth counts. Heck, I almost want to try it myself as I have quite a few EM clutches laying around, and the ability to make a electronic paddle shifter for the cause. >:D
 

jman231994

New member
Messages
724
Reaction score
3
Location
Australia
One improvement I will add is that you should replace the low range clutch with a one-way needle bearing. You should also look for an engine with a powerful charging system (maybe you could add your own?).

This is a concept I have been thinking about recently and this might help me a bit here so I will share. It's not that useful I think for kart use, more for efficiency, but what if you used the alternator as the power source from the clutch. So that at low revs it is in the first gear but as soon as revs increase from decreased load it would shift to the second gear due to the alternator increasing the output power enough to engage the Electro clutch....... Its more an rpm based gearbox rather than a torque based setup.....I call copyright on that one if its not been done before :thumbsup:
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
I honestly think an alternator is too parasitic to be useful here. However, the right electronics guru could probably make up a counter circuit (think tach or speedo) that could trigger a relay and work the clutch at the right time.
 

r97

Measure twice cut once
Messages
3,793
Reaction score
9
Location
Massachusetts, USA
IMO, in the direction this is headng I think it would make more sense to make a conventional 2 speed jack shaft, less weight, no elctronics, and smooth engagement. But if your intersted in the novelty of the electromagnetic clutches I would understand that and I would still be very excited to see it!
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
Well, not every idea we explore is purely for practicality. Sometimes it's just for proof-of-concept, or bench-bragging rights. At any rate (for scientific purposes), I'd like to see this attempted.
 

Jcotz

...wasn't there
Messages
374
Reaction score
1
Location
NY
A while ago, I had a similar idea using centrifugal clutches, but sort of hit a wall when thinking about how to get the other to disengage. I hope this works for you though.
 

B.M.800

TheBeal.
Messages
2,387
Reaction score
26
Location
Central PA
Considering centrifugal clutches cannot engage backwards (the drivetrain would just spin the outer clutch bell) downshifting would be fine aslong as you let off the gas and let the shoes disengage.

This idea is actually very plausible if you can change the pulleys out for sprockets of different tooth counts. Heck, I almost want to try it myself as I have quite a few EM clutches laying around, and the ability to make a electronic paddle shifter for the cause. >:D

Yes, you explained it better. Oh, and send me some of those E-clutches why doncha.
:D

IMO, in the direction this is headng I think it would make more sense to make a conventional 2 speed jack shaft, less weight, no elctronics, and smooth engagement. But if your intersted in the novelty of the electromagnetic clutches I would understand that and I would still be very excited to see it!

Well, seems I cant seem to understand how quite how exactly they would work... I would like to see a diagram of how they work... Then making one? Again, I dont quite know how that work, Im not sure how exactly I would make some.

Im one of them people who likes to actually see something, or better yet have it in my hands to fiddle with it. Its kinda hart for me to envision how something works jus by words...
 

HellSpawn

New member
Messages
476
Reaction score
2
Location
Wadena, Minnesota


Basically, 2 clutches. starts off in low gear going to a normal sprocket with a one-way bearing. Then RPMs on the jackshaft increase and the second clutch engages.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top