a fellow user and i had a disagreement on tensioner placement awhile back. his take on it was that while tensioning from below seems like a good idea, the engine pulls the top of the belt, slacking the underside. the torque of the engine would tend to cause the tensioner to come unseated. not his words, but the gist of what i remember of the conversation. running the tensioner at the top made more sense, though i can't tell you why it did.