2 cycle vs 4 cycle

2 cycle or 4 cycle

  • 2 cycle

    Votes: 9 47.4%
  • 4 cycle

    Votes: 10 52.6%

  • Total voters
    19
Status
Not open for further replies.

brandongeiger2

New member
Messages
584
Reaction score
0
Location
Valrico Florida
Finally, (since I'm trying to kill the last minutes of class) why is it that someone has yet to come up with a 2 stroke which is just as efficient as a 4 stroke? Why can't the compression take place in another area beside the crankcase. While it's a really simple, and even ingenious creation, it has flaws which I'm surprised allowed them to be sold on the market for decades so widely. I assume in a small engine (49cc=<) the cylinder is ported and half of the fuel escapes through the exhaust. How about the expansion chamber on my pocket bike? Does this awkwardly-shaped pipe REALLY stop fuel from leaking out, just because it's got a funny curve? I still have a lot to research about 2 strokes, but I hope this helps a bit.


Id say the reason two strokes seem somewhat primitive and inefficient is because the EPA hates them...they pollute a lot and if they dont allow certain Bikes and quads or just the engines they cant be improved upon much but id bet if as much effort that has been put into researching and building 4 strokes was used for production and design of two strokes they would be used much more widely

Also about the expansion chamber its formed to create back pressure it affects int/ex timing and has something to do with scavenging but thats all i really know
 

Brandon1023

needs an oil change
Messages
422
Reaction score
4
Location
Miami, Florida, Dade County 305
Also some good points from Brandon1023. You really could go back and forth on this for quite some time. Truth is, in my opinion it is something you'd want to evaluate on a case-by-case basis. Under some circumstances, a 2-stroke is preferable, and others- a 4.
The purpose of a multiple ratio power transmission is to optimize the use of an engine's power band. 2-stroke or 4, final ratios would help level the playing field.

Personally, I see the assets and liabilities to both. If you ask "which do I prefer?", I can't answer. Depends what I want to accomplish with it.

Thanks, Toystory. This thread kind of made me realize.. Everyone has an opinion, and it's only normal to "reject our reality and substitute your own." haha. And yea. That's what I tried to say in my previous post. They both have their own specialties and each have a big list of pros, and a big list of cons which I could spend a while typing, but no one wants to read that.

I just thought of a pretty good example:
You won't need a gx200 on your weedeater pole or whatever it's called. Simply because the gx200 revs at a max of 3600 RPM, while a weedie can rev up to ~6000 RPM without any problems. Infact, they are governed much higher than 4 strokes. They may or may not rev high enough to spin the head fast enough to cut grass. PLUS, the engine weighs a good 40 pounds AND due to the nature of the lubrication system, the engine must remain pretty flat to run without problems. BUT the engine has enough "muscle" or torque to spin a big magnetic coil in a generator, as well as be used in dozens of other applications and not need to be carried as much. On the other hand, the 26cc 2 stroke engine is not nearly enough to turn that big alternator for the generator, BUT it's portable and light since it fires every up and down movement of the piston as people say. Do you see how each one has their own benefits and let downs? Personally, I think 2 strokes should be limited to equipment such as lawn tools and similar applications. They should re-design the 2 stroke either from scratch, or modify the existing design. I imagine if there was a way to inject the mixture at the right time in to the cylinder (much like a 2 stroke diesel engine), this would solve a good deal of problems. Of course, you now need to design a way to time the injection of the fuel. I'm getting off here now before I type all night.
 

matman55

I dont have a camera!!
Messages
507
Reaction score
0
Location
Mims FL
What if you had the choice between a v-twin 98CI 2stoke and v-twin 98CI 4 stroke?

4 stroke.i choose that for the application.im looking for fuel effieciency of a motorcycle.plus that thing is heavy as **** so i need a engine that can go up hills without a problem.
 

matman55

I dont have a camera!!
Messages
507
Reaction score
0
Location
Mims FL
Personally, I see the assets and liabilities to both. If you ask "which do I prefer?", I can't answer. Depends what I want to accomplish with it.

:iagree: Compleatly. Ide use a 4 stroke for a racing dirt bike all day. But when it comes to my weed wacker its a 2 stroke.
 
Last edited:

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
Actually, I really like my 2-stroke snowblower. It's a Toro CCR3650. The 2-stroke 141cc R*TEK engine (piston-ported version of the LB DuraForce) makes the unit very light and manoeuvrable. I only have to use it to clear my walkway, as I use a tractor for the driveway. I was using a Craftsman 6-24 4-stroke before, and the Toro is sooo much nicer for the purpose. THIS is one of those circumstances where the 2-stroke is king. I can even carry it down the steps to do around back without killing myself. That simply was not possible with my old Crapsman...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top