2 cycle vs 4 cycle

2 cycle or 4 cycle

  • 2 cycle

    Votes: 9 47.4%
  • 4 cycle

    Votes: 10 52.6%

  • Total voters
    19
Status
Not open for further replies.

DS13

Annoying the Neighbors!!!
Messages
437
Reaction score
0
Location
Elysburg, PA
i don't know why i put cycle i meant stroke i was thinking one thing while typing another:oops:
 

r_chez_08

Should be in the shop...
Messages
4,827
Reaction score
14
Location
Cornwall, UK
For what? What are we comparing? Displacement? HP? Torque? Rpm? Cost?
I would pick a 4 cycle 6.5 clone over a 2 cycle weedwacker, however I would pick a 2 cycle 250 bike engine over the stock 4 cycle 6.5 clone.
 

matman55

I dont have a camera!!
Messages
507
Reaction score
0
Location
Mims FL
yeah,2 stroke all day.ide rather have power every revolution than every other revolution
 

brandongeiger2

New member
Messages
584
Reaction score
0
Location
Valrico Florida
two stroke "If you aint mixin gas you aint haulin ***!" as many say haha
-cheaper rebuilds
-more affective power curve
-lower weight
-Sound
-Smell
-Braaappp
 

DS13

Annoying the Neighbors!!!
Messages
437
Reaction score
0
Location
Elysburg, PA
For what? What are we comparing? Displacement? HP? Torque? Rpm? Cost?

just as a general comparison.. i know 2 strokes have more power and 4 strokes last longer. i just wanted to see what you guys thought.

i was looking at the 420cc harbor freight engine and my buddy said i should go with a 2 stroke so i didnt know what to do
 

Jake.B

New member
Messages
495
Reaction score
0
Location
California-USA
Well it depends on what you want. If you have a 2 stroke 250cc dirtbike and a 4 stroke 250cc dirtbike and say the same rider same skills, a 4 stoke 9/10 times wins around the track. In a straight up drag race 2 stroke usually wins in the end. 2 strokes make more power but it is only effective in the powerband. 4 strokes that powerband is always there. Meaning faster corner takeoff, faster off the line take off and faster gear climbing. 2-stokes have higher rpm ranges for more speed, and in that powerband they are tons of fun to ride.
 

Brandon1023

needs an oil change
Messages
422
Reaction score
4
Location
Miami, Florida, Dade County 305
I have the 420cc Predator and I'm very pleased with it. Horse Power and torque are not an issue for me anymore. you don't have to worry about mixing the correct ratio or breathing that repulsive burning/un-burnt oil/gas, and mine came with an electric start. Another nice thing is that you can have the peace of mind knowing that you're not losing half of the gasoline in each power stroke, right out the muffler! Fires right up after a turn of the key. Maybe it's bigger than a 2 stroke, but if you take care of it, it will probably last twice as long. Finally, I'm pleased with the low amount of noise mine puts out. I had a 6.5 Tech and that thing was 50% louder than the Clone. A 2 stroke is an annoying thing to have right behind you while you ride around. This is my opinion however. Haters gonna hate on 4 strokes and life goes on. I say go for it.

Edit: Not sure how efficient it is, but if you get a big enough alternator, you can turn it in to an 8500W electrical generator. Pretty handy living in Florida where hurricanes knock the power out for a week.
 

OzFab

Well-known member
Messages
15,615
Reaction score
76
Location
Warwick Qld, Australia
Each has thier own merits: 2 stroke have great torque down low but point it at a hill & it dies, a 4 stroke will climb hills all day.

I think all my other points have already been covered...
 

brandongeiger2

New member
Messages
584
Reaction score
0
Location
Valrico Florida
Well it depends on what you want. If you have a 2 stroke 250cc dirtbike and a 4 stroke 250cc dirtbike and say the same rider same skills, a 4 stoke 9/10 times wins around the track. In a straight up drag race 2 stroke usually wins in the end. 2 strokes make more power but it is only effective in the powerband. 4 strokes that powerband is always there. Meaning faster corner takeoff, faster off the line take off and faster gear climbing. 2-stokes have higher rpm ranges for more speed, and in that powerband they are tons of fun to ride.

actually im going to have to disagree...

a 250cc two stroke bike is only raced against 450 four strokes and 125cc two strokes run with the 250 four strokes if you put a 250 two stroke on the track with a 250 four stroke the two stroke will have the advantage.
every race ive seen and every track ive raced at runs 250 2ts with 450 4ts and 125 2ts with 250 4ts. If you look at the power and torque curves youd understand what i mean.

Also the four stroke power curve basically flatlines after a certain rpm two stroke power curves are almost exponential to a point ive gone from riding a two stroke to riding a four and its very different its almost like the "power bands" are opposite.
 

DS13

Annoying the Neighbors!!!
Messages
437
Reaction score
0
Location
Elysburg, PA
Brandon1023 has convinced me to get the 420... besides the 420 is relatively cheap and im not made of money.:(
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
Depends where your priorities lay. The one thing that simply cannot be argued is the power to weight ratio. Pound for pound, a 2-stroke with the same displacement as a comparable 4-stroke will kick the spit out of the 4-stroke. Case in point-

4-stroke: Honda GX140- 144cc, 5Hp@3600 RPM 30.9lbs
2-stroke:Lawn Boy DuraForce- 141cc, 6.5Hp@3200RPM 22.4lbs

Immediately, we notice three things- 1)Although the displacement is the same, the LB weighs 8.5lbs less than the Honda. 2)The LB makes 1.5hp more than the Honda 3)The LB makes its rated hp at 400 RPM lower than the Honda. Extrapolating typical HP curves, we can very safely assume the LB exceeds 6.5hp when spinning 3600 RPM when comparing to the Honda at the same speed.

What it boils down to, is the "Power To Weight Ratio", which is typically shown as HP/Lb. The Honda calcs out to 0.16HP per pound. The LB works out to 0.29HP per pound. That's awfully close to DOUBLE the power per unit of weight. In theory, that means of you had a LB engine weighing the same 30.9Lbs, it would be a 9hp engine!

Basically, anytime you free up weight, you make better use of your available power. The above comparison is a double win for the LB- It's quite a bit lighter (which effectively adds power) and it boasts 1.5 more HP on top of it all!

FWIW- I pulled the Honda's weight spec off the 'net- and I ran out to the garage and weighed my Duraforce. Since the Honda includes a fuel tank, I dropped my factory LB tank on the scale to make it fair. My scale is an Ohaus digital commercial scale, legal for trade.

Now- Noise- I cut my lawn with a model F lawn boy- and I do not think it's any louder than any number of small 4-strokes I have around here. Also- there's a lot to be said about mufflers, which would have to be compared separately.

Yes, you DO have to mix your fuel. Once you're used to it, it's not a big deal. Some 2-strokes don't even require a mix. They take straight pump gas. The oil is injected automatically from a separate reservoir.

Smoke? Not much at all. Running the proper mix ratio with the proper oil in an engine in good shape makes little to no smoke. My old, beat up LB-F only smokes visibly when cold. Once you're warmed up and off choke, you see nothing.

Longevity- 2-Stroke outboard motors last forever- look around. Like anything, treat it right, and it'll go forever. They are smaller, lighter, simpler, less moving parts. Let's talk reliability.

Efficiency- Hey! Seriously? This is a GO KART!!! (Or whatever). I burnt $8000.00 in fuel driving to work last year. None of that went into my lawnmower, snowblower, or weedwhacker. At that point, do you really think I give a rat's rearend if the R*TEK in my Toro CCR3650 snowblower is maybe a bit less efficient than it could be???

Let me say this- I'm not "hating on" anything. I love these engines. Without any doubt, the Honda GX series is my favourite 4-stroke industrial engine, I do love them. This purpose of this argument was to "show the other side".
 

Brandon1023

needs an oil change
Messages
422
Reaction score
4
Location
Miami, Florida, Dade County 305
Toystory proves a lot in that post. I was just pointing out all the benefits that I look at in my 420cc. 2-strokes and I have a love/hate relationship. Occasionally, I like a whiff of that oil smell and I like to (and I know this is somewhat contradicting my original post but we're all hypocritical to some extent lol.) but in my opinion I'd rather use a 4-stroke. I know everyone has different opinions on the 2 types of engines, and I'm not trying to convert anyone to love 4 strokes as much as me. I feel like the debate between 2 and 4 stroke engines is similar to discussing politics hahaa. With me, 2 strokes have an infamous reputation of giving your right arm a good work out from the continuous pulling. In my opinion, I think 2 strokes should be limited to small applications under 30cc like weedeaters and chainsaws - things that don't use any gearing which require high RPM.

(for those who don't know.. 2 strokes generally rev much higher (~10,000 RPM) but don't put out as much torque. Think of a weedeater- The head with the line cuts grass because it spins so fast, the line becomes invisible. However, it's my understanding that 2 strokes deliver less torque. Case and point would be my pocket bike. 49cc and it used to go about 20 mph with my (in 2005) 10 year old a$$ sittin on it. Sure it revved high, but that clutch would've BURNED if it didn't have a 2:1 gear ratio. It wasn't the small amount of torque which got me going, it was the fact that the crankshaft had to spin twice for every time the rear sprocket turned. This sounds complicated, but reading it over a couple times and searching up [gear reduction, torque, power band, etc] would explain things much better.

The power band is the range of RPM at which the engine will make the most power. Suppose a 2 stroke only makes good power between 5,000 and 7,000 RPM. Anything under it, and you'll be revving too slow for any real power. Then, once you hit the band, the amount of power being produced suddenly jumps. Obviously 5,000-7,000 RPM is not accurate. I came up with those for the sake of trying to explain. In a 4 stroke, the power band is much wider meaning you can make about the same power at almost all the RPM ranges allowed by the engine's limits. If I explained anything wrong, I welcome someone to quote it and point it out to help me, and everyone reading this thread.

Finally, (since I'm trying to kill the last minutes of class) why is it that someone has yet to come up with a 2 stroke which is just as efficient as a 4 stroke? Why can't the compression take place in another area beside the crankcase. While it's a really simple, and even ingenious creation, it has flaws which I'm surprised allowed them to be sold on the market for decades so widely. I assume in a small engine (49cc=<) the cylinder is ported and half of the fuel escapes through the exhaust. How about the expansion chamber on my pocket bike? Does this awkwardly-shaped pipe REALLY stop fuel from leaking out, just because it's got a funny curve? I still have a lot to research about 2 strokes, but I hope this helps a bit.
 

matman55

I dont have a camera!!
Messages
507
Reaction score
0
Location
Mims FL
ide rather have a a v-twin 98ci 4 stroke engine in my dads heritage softtail than a 2 stroke.
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
Also some good points from Brandon1023. You really could go back and forth on this for quite some time. Truth is, in my opinion it is something you'd want to evaluate on a case-by-case basis. Under some circumstances, a 2-stroke is preferable, and others- a 4.
The purpose of a multiple ratio power transmission is to optimize the use of an engine's power band. 2-stroke or 4, final ratios would help level the playing field.

Personally, I see the assets and liabilities to both. If you ask "which do I prefer?", I can't answer. Depends what I want to accomplish with it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top