These would be my normal two recommendations that I'd tell someone at work, for reference I'm a Maintenance Manger in a plastics plant.
Tighten all four up evenly in sequence until one of them strips the threads or shears the head off, then back the other three off 1/8 turn. This is the one I give for small fasteners. On large fasteners, the torque spec is a three foot cheater and two grunts.
Luckily no one follows the advice on small fasteners, and neither should you! Personally I use a 1/4" ratchet held close to the head and snug them. The valve cover gaskets I've gotten were a thicker cork material that compress and seal pretty good without having to crank down on the bolts.