the other way around, weak springs mean very early engagement.
But shoes can lock up from dirt or rust or debris...
Also, not every clutch is meant to run on every engine.
You can't run a 2stroke clutch on your 4stroke engine for example;
mainly because racing 2 stroke clutches engage at around 4000-4500 rpm
[yes settable, but that's not uncommon],
and the common 4stroke engine governs at 3600 rpm so way below needed rpms.
you could also have forgotten (or sheared) your key, so the clutch engages properly, but the missing key is allowing the crank to run inside the clutch which will then disengage again...
So, post pics, specs if you have them and we'll find the cause
and will likely be able to point you in the right direction.
difference, the left one is a maxtorque (or clone) SS, the right one a Noram (or clone) I guess.
different shoe design, different springs, bells etc...
(set screws are on the backside of the maxtorque in case you need them)
but if the right one is what I think it is,
there will be no noteworthy difference on a std fun kart.
Both will engage at about the same rpm (1800-2000) both will withstand only minor abuse before frying up and both will be in about the same price range;
'sid