straight pipe or muffler?

Status
Not open for further replies.

beansdaddy78

JR. Member
Messages
565
Reaction score
2
Location
Carbondale IL.
hey i was putting my 5hp briggs back together and i have an exhuast of another briggs that happens to fit. It is a long pipe with the muffler on the end and hangs out beyond the gas tank. the muffler can be removed from the pipe leaving a straight pipe.

so what i am wanting to know is, will running the motor with just a straight pipe out of the exhaust?, will it ruin it? are there any negatives, or positives? and which would you ride with?

Does a straight pipe add power at all?
 

Jcotz

...wasn't there
Messages
374
Reaction score
1
Location
NY
You will probably experience a slight increase in power, but not too much. It will however, be louder and have a bit of a different sound.
 

r_chez_08

Should be in the shop...
Messages
4,827
Reaction score
14
Location
Cornwall, UK
Negatives-
F*cking loud,
IMO will probably sound bad,
May produce less torque
Pisses off the neighbours

Positives-
May produce more power if the muffler is restrictive

IMO I would run the muffler. A straight pipe is highly unlikely to ruin the engine, however, I have heard that with an unrestrictive muffler these engines can make more (ever so marginally) bottom end torque.
 

beansdaddy78

JR. Member
Messages
565
Reaction score
2
Location
Carbondale IL.
you guys make good points, i do live in the country so im not too worried about the neighbors (they have hated me since i started getting these toys anyway)
well seeing i think you said its not likely to ruin the motor, what i may do is try them both out and see if there is any difference using my cell phone with a speedometer app. and i guess i can make two landmarks and time it to see if acceleration increased at all.
 

gixxerkart

Big Boss
Messages
240
Reaction score
0
Location
high desert
Actually you will gain something up top in the rpm band and lose a lot of torque in the lower rpm band. It will be contingent on your cam profile and head ports. If upgraded and governor removed you'll enjoy it. If its a stock motor your take off will suck.
 

gixxerkart

Big Boss
Messages
240
Reaction score
0
Location
high desert
Basically you want back pressure because it forms a tiny pocket of vacuum at the exhaust port and when the exhaust valve is opened it will literally "suck" the spent gases out of the combustion chamber. If its just straight pipe you will lose that Venturi effect. ****... I guess it paid off studying race engine theory...
 

Jcotz

...wasn't there
Messages
374
Reaction score
1
Location
NY
another point to make though...the straight pipe may lean the mixture, correct? Then he will be able to use a (albeit slightly) larger jet and have some more power. correct me if I'm wrong.
 

Russ2251

AZUSA:Powered by LAWN-BOY
Messages
6,622
Reaction score
47
Location
Huntington Station, Long Island, NY
Forget the cell phone app. Inconclusive at best.
GPS is just as unreliable. I was clocked at 51mph while a Garmin GPS said I was doing 17mph. I believe the Audi speedo.
Use a known distance, tachometer, and a stop watch. Make ten runs each, with and without pipe.
You will see a difference. Document and show us the results.
Straight pipe (no muff) will yield about a .5hp gain.
Back pressure is not necessary.
 

exenos

Project Nut
Messages
1,217
Reaction score
0
Location
Ontario, Canada
You have no idea how badly I want to scream. No engine needs back pressure. All it does is restrict the flow of exhaust gazes. So many people get the idea of back pressure from the pressure waves that are created by a expansion chamber. The pressure waves push any escaping fuel/air mix back into the cylinder, which is not needed on a four stroke because of the exhaust valves.
Again, you do not need any back pressure at all.
 

Russ2251

AZUSA:Powered by LAWN-BOY
Messages
6,622
Reaction score
47
Location
Huntington Station, Long Island, NY
I very recently saw a post on this forum where it was stated you will "crystallize" the valves if you run straight exhaust. Poster did not elaborate or offer proof...and never will.
In 4+ decades of small engine service, I have never witnessed this.
 

newrider3

New member
Messages
1,674
Reaction score
5
Location
Colorado
I think people often confuse having backpressure, and having an actual tuned exhaust system. Tuning for a four-stroke exhaust requires some math to determine the optimal tube diameter and length based on your preferred RPM range. You can even use a diverging cone (megaphone) design, or in the case of a multi-cylinder header, a collector and tuned length primaries, to get a scavenging effect to pull spent gasses out of the port faster.

For the average Briggs yard kart, it's not worth the engineering. Just bung a 12" long 1/2" or 3/4" NPT pipe nipple in the exhaust port and call it good.
 

beansdaddy78

JR. Member
Messages
565
Reaction score
2
Location
Carbondale IL.
Forget the cell phone app. Inconclusive at best.
GPS is just as unreliable. I was clocked at 51mph while a Garmin GPS said I was doing 17mph. I believe the Audi speedo.
Use a known distance, tachometer, and a stop watch. Make ten runs each, with and without pipe.
You will see a difference. Document and show us the results.
Straight pipe (no muff) will yield about a .5hp gain.
Back pressure is not necessary.
i guess im lucky then or my speedometer on my car is off exactly the same, it seems to be dead on with my vehicle and moped speedometer.
 

beansdaddy78

JR. Member
Messages
565
Reaction score
2
Location
Carbondale IL.
I think people often confuse having backpressure, and having an actual tuned exhaust system. Tuning for a four-stroke exhaust requires some math to determine the optimal tube diameter and length based on your preferred RPM range. You can even use a diverging cone (megaphone) design, or in the case of a multi-cylinder header, a collector and tuned length primaries, to get a scavenging effect to pull spent gasses out of the port faster.

For the average Briggs yard kart, it's not worth the engineering. Just bung a 12" long 1/2" or 3/4" NPT pipe nipple in the exhaust port and call it good.
its for my margay panther, an old kart but still decent at least in my opinion
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
Once again we see an example of a confusion of the terms "back pressure" and "cylinder scavenging".

When I did the speedo mod on my kart, I calibrated it according to as accurate a measurement as I could muster. I grabbed my old Magellen GPS and did 10 long full throttle passes of about 2 minutes each in both directions up and down my road. I then calculated and average of the 10 passes, and that avergae was within 1 km/h (0.6 MPH) of what the speedo said. Then, I took those numbers, and back-checked them thru my speed calc program to verify engine RPM and wheel RPM. It all agreed. On the other hand, I have been doing tests on my kids' kart, and I could NOT get a reliable or believeable read off my NEW Magellan GPS. So much for technological advancements!...
 

OzFab

Well-known member
Messages
15,615
Reaction score
76
Location
Warwick Qld, Australia
You have no idea how badly I want to scream. No engine needs back pressure. All it does is restrict the flow of exhaust gazes. So many people get the idea of back pressure from the pressure waves that are created by a expansion chamber. The pressure waves push any escaping fuel/air mix back into the cylinder, which is not needed on a four stroke because of the exhaust valves.
Again, you do not need any back pressure at all.

Anyone whose ever burned an exhaust valve will disagree with you :roflol:
 

Doc Sprocket

*********
Messages
15,677
Reaction score
153
Location
Ontario, Canada
There are those that would suggest that running open port (no exhaust), will cause valve damage. I woudnt know. However- running a stright pipe, or "open header" creates a thermal barrier to guard againt this alleged problem. Folks have run open headers in all sorts of race applications for decades...
 

OzFab

Well-known member
Messages
15,615
Reaction score
76
Location
Warwick Qld, Australia
There are those that would suggest that running open port (no exhaust), will cause valve damage. I woudnt know. However- running a stright pipe, or "open header" creates a thermal barrier to guard againt this alleged problem. Folks have run open headers in all sorts of race applications for decades...

:iagree: The fact is, any sort of pipe, header, whatever, will provide enough restriction to guard against valve damage providing the pipe is closely matched to the size of the port; too big & you get close to the open port effect. As stated, open port will cause damage because there's no restriction at all
 

Badot

New member
Messages
677
Reaction score
3
From a safety standpoint though...

If you're putting it on something you've built yourself, you'll probably want to hear when something comes loose and starts rattling rather than hearing the pipe.

Just my personal opinion.
 

gixxerkart

Big Boss
Messages
240
Reaction score
0
Location
high desert
You have no idea how badly I want to scream. No engine needs back pressure. All it does is restrict the flow of exhaust gazes. So many people get the idea of back pressure from the pressure waves that are created by a expansion chamber. The pressure waves push any escaping fuel/air mix back into the cylinder, which is not needed on a four stroke because of the exhaust valves.
Again, you do not need any back pressure at all.


SOMEONE needs to read up on four stroke engine theory...;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top