Broached keyway vs milled keyway

Status
Not open for further replies.

r_chez_08

Should be in the shop...
Messages
4,827
Reaction score
14
Location
Cornwall, UK
My clone crankshaft has chips in the end of it from where the torque converter fell off. I was going to strip down the motor and weld and re machine the crank. However, the keyway is damaged so I may fill it in with weld.

When I redo the keyway I will have to mill it not broach it. This means the end will be rounded rather than "tapering off"
I understand that most axles and jackshafts are milled, is there any reason cranks are broached?

Thanks
Rob
 

TorqueRanger

New member
Messages
257
Reaction score
1
I am not really understanding what broaching is but I would just fill the metal area in and take it on a lathe and turn it back to stock spec and just use a milling machine with a flat end milling bit to mill the key way.... I turned my drill press into a mill machine for little stuff...
 

Rustydog2010

NZ Nutta :|
Messages
945
Reaction score
2
Location
New Zealand
Welding the crank? I'm not to sure about that. I doubt that crankshafts are just mild steel. If you were to weld it, it will probably destroy the hardness/temper of it. Add that it would be like trying to weld a bearing race - very difficult. Unless you are going to get it re-tempered?

If it was mine, I would be tempted to turn down the crank about 1/4", will in a key way. Then make up a 1/4" sleeve to go over it with another key way in it. I think there are some pictures floating around, if you don't get it.

Just some food for thought.
 

r_chez_08

Should be in the shop...
Messages
4,827
Reaction score
14
Location
Cornwall, UK
Thanks for your reply :)
I have heard of people welding adapters and extra lengths to their cranks etc. The thing is I already have one adapter from 3/4" to 1" and I wouldnt want one from, say, 1/2" to 3/4". I could go 1/2" to 1" i guess, but I dont think 1/2" would be strong enough.

Do you think I could heat it up and dunk it in oil to re temper? And maybe use salt water or charcoal to induce extra carbon?

I would use high carbon welding rods. I have made jackshafts from mild steel and their keyways have held up, so would the crank not be ok?
I would obviously remove it from the engine.
 

r_chez_08

Should be in the shop...
Messages
4,827
Reaction score
14
Location
Cornwall, UK
I am not really understanding what broaching is but I would just fill the metal area in and take it on a lathe and turn it back to stock spec and just use a milling machine with a flat end milling bit to mill the key way.... I turned my drill press into a mill machine for little stuff...

Yeah i was planning to fill all the holes with a stick welder and high carbon rod, then machine to almost 3/4" (it is now 20mm but i would prefer 3/4" - more common) and I would use a toolpost grinder to get it to 3/4". Then I was going to re mill the slot, with a 3/16" cutter on a mill at school.

Broaching is a process where the metal is almost "shaved" off, a bit like a chisel. I cannot do this process though, so wondered if milling would suffice?
 

Benjo

KRAZY KIWI
Messages
371
Reaction score
0
Location
New Plymouth,Taranaki, New Zealand
External keyways are not broached they are milled one of two ways,
only internal keyways are broached.
Broaches are shaped similar to a saw, except the teeth height increases over the length of the tool

 

r_chez_08

Should be in the shop...
Messages
4,827
Reaction score
14
Location
Cornwall, UK
Thanks for that benjo, that makes sense now.
I thought the keyway in the first picture had been broached. I may be able to cut it like that.
Sorry for any confusion torque ranger with my incorrect broaching definition.

Which is the best method for my use, pic 1 or pic 2?
And will the crank hold up to welding?
 

mckutzy

Well-known member
Messages
8,353
Reaction score
113
Location
bc, canada
Dont weld the shaft, especially with a stck, tig would be the most you would want, it most likely will break or at least chip when machined. I also wouldnt try to reheat and try to temper the thing either, unless your are really familiar with the process and know the metallurgical composition of the work involved. If any of this lets go, the rod is going up (predominantly where your A$$ is, or near your arm when in a Kart) none the less not good.

Milling a wider key is a way to go, but when ever a sleeve is used, typically you will not have as much strength as if it were one piece. The shaft will have a small lip that the key will sit in and the rest will float on the shaft. The sleeve might spin and twist the key thus having much less holding power when needed. An Idea is if you have the sleeve on the shaft and drill a hole cross wise to the axis of the key through the sleeve and shaft, pin it in place. This helps to strengthen the arrangement. Easy way to do this all, make the sleeve a tube and fit it to the shaft, pin the sleeve, mill the keyway through. As allways use plenty of coolant.

Set up for the shaft will need several V blocks or an indexing head with centers that can accommodate the crank depth.
Here is an example (small pic sorry).

It will need to be sturdy and precise none the less.
 

r_chez_08

Should be in the shop...
Messages
4,827
Reaction score
14
Location
Cornwall, UK
Ok plan 2: interference fit.
I thought I would post this up to see what you guys thought:
1. Lathe crankshaft diameter to .500
2. Lathe sleeve (either mild or silver steel) .496 i/d .780 o/d
3. Heat up sleeve to cherry red, and slide/ tap onto crankshaft.
4. Lathe crank to .750"
5. Cut a keyway 3/16" wide 3/32" deep.
This creates a very strong interferance "friction" fit.

Another option would be to do the same as this except 1", so no additional sleeve with keyway is required. I have 2 problems with this however:
1. Resale value/ crankshaft size for future use.
2. How big is the gx200 crank bearing?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top