I took it out today for another test run. 2 hours of solid dirt-karting and no mechanical issues apart from one of my shifter cables slipping tiny bit, fixed with half a turn on the adjuster.
I ran a circuit shifting up and down gears and while the box does require a bit of mothering it engages fairly easily (most of the time, 4 out of 5 times). You definitely have to lay off the throttle when shifting though. The way I have it worked is you have to take your hand of the throttle lever to shift anyway, but shifting with revs results in quite a bit of clash on the dog clutch. Sometimes the clutch just doesn't want to engage and you end up coming to a stop before you can get it to shift into gear, this is a bit of a pain and means you have to plan your shifts a bit more.
I think in v2.0 I would concentrate more on the dog/clutch geometry the stud and hole system is pretty unforgiving when the whole lot is spinning. Something with a tapered edged teeth would probably work more reliably, but would a tapered tooth also try to disengage when coasting, or worse partly engage while spinning rapidly and spit teeth all over the back of my head?
There are a number of off-the-shelf dog-clutch mechanism designs that might be worth using as inspiration...
@r97: Its about AUD$350 for the; sprockets x6, 3/4" shafts x2, bearings x4, chains x10foot length, and square tube 4', 1/4" plate, bolts, keysteel and to have the 20x50mm clutch boss turned. All the bits I couldn't make myself.
So yeah, not as cheap as using a free motorcycle engine like I have on my previous Karts.
I hope you guys can improve on my design and come up with better designs.